Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose between a public trust and the State of Gujarat regarding the demand for education cess for the year 1985-86. The petitioner, Uttar Gujarat Jain Visha Oswal Samaj Trust, challenged the demand of Rs.2567.60 towards education cess, arguing that the building in question, a dharamshala, was incomplete during the relevant period. The petitioner sought an injunction against the collection of this cess by the Chief Officer of Palitana Municipality. The court noted that the respondent's only response was a vague denial of the building's incomplete status, failing to address the factual contention raised by the petitioner. The court emphasized the necessity of providing notice and an opportunity for hearing before imposing such a demand. Consequently, the court quashed the demand notice and directed the respondent to reconsider the matter, allowing the petitioner to raise all relevant points, including the argument against the levy of education cess on dharamshalas. The court ordered that the matter be decided afresh within three months of receiving the certified copy of the order, with no costs awarded.
Headnote
A) Taxation Law - Education Cess - Levy on Incomplete Building - Gujarat Municipalities Act, 1963 - Court held that education cess could not be levied on an incomplete building of a public trust without proper notice and opportunity for hearing. The demand for education cess was quashed, and the matter was remanded for fresh consideration regarding the building's status (Paras 3-4).
Issue of Consideration
Whether education cess can be levied on an incomplete building of a public trust.
Final Decision
The court allowed the special civil application, quashed the demand notice, and directed the respondent to decide the matter afresh after providing notice and opportunity for hearing within three months.
Law Points
- Education cess
- public trust property
- incomplete building
- notice and hearing requirements




