High Court Dismisses Appeal on Compassionate Appointment Grounds — No Employment Relationship Established.

  • 6
Judgement Image
Font size:
Print

Case Note & Summary

The case involved a Letters Patent Appeal filed by Ghanshyambhai D Dabhi against the rejection of his petition for compassionate appointment following the death of his father, who was employed as a Lineman. The appellant applied for the appointment jointly with his mother after his father's death on 7th December 1992. Initially, the respondent issued an appointment order on 19th October 1993, but it was later withdrawn on the grounds that the appellant had concealed the fact that his elder brother was already employed with the respondent. The appellant contended that the cancellation of the appointment without a hearing was illegal and argued that his brother lived separately. The learned Single Judge found no employer-employee relationship and concluded that the petition was not tenable. The appellant's counsel argued for the right to be heard before cancellation, but the court noted that no legal right was created by the mere issuance of the appointment order. The court also addressed the appellant's claims regarding other appointments made in contravention of GSO 295, stating that any illegal appointments should be addressed by the respondents. The court ultimately dismissed the appeal but allowed the appellant to make a fresh representation for compassionate appointment, which should be considered on its merits without influence from the dismissal of the previous petitions.

Headnote

A) Employment Law - Compassionate Appointment - Legality of Cancellation - Gujarat Service Rules, 1959, GSO 295 - The court held that the cancellation of the appointment order was not illegal as no employment relationship was established and the appellant had not joined duty. The court noted that the appellant's brother was employed and living with the family, which justified the cancellation of the appointment order without a hearing. Held that the appellant could make a fresh representation for compassionate appointment which should be considered on merits (Paras 1-10).

Subscribe to unlock Headnote Subscribe Now

Issue of Consideration

Whether the cancellation of the appointment order without a hearing was legal and whether the appellant was entitled to compassionate appointment despite having an employed brother.

Subscribe to unlock Issue of Consideration Subscribe Now

Final Decision

The appeal was dismissed with no order as to costs, but the court allowed the appellant to make a fresh representation for compassionate appointment, which should be considered on its merits.

Law Points

  • Compassionate appointment
  • Right to be heard
  • Employment relationship
  • GSO 295
  • GSO 305
Subscribe to unlock Law Points Subscribe Now

Case Details

Letters Patent Appeal No 739 of 1994

1996-04-24

C.K. Thakker, S.D. Pandit

R.D. Raval

Ghanshyambhai D Dabhi

GEB

Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more) Subscribe Now

Nature of Litigation

Letters Patent Appeal against rejection of compassionate appointment petition.

Remedy Sought

Ghanshyambhai D Dabhi sought reinstatement of his compassionate appointment.

Filing Reason

Cancellation of appointment order without a hearing.

Previous Decisions

The learned Single Judge rejected the petition on grounds of no employer-employee relationship.

Issues

Legality of cancellation of appointment order Right to be heard before cancellation

Submissions/Arguments

Appellant argued for the right to be heard before cancellation Respondent contended that no legal right was created by the appointment order

Ratio Decidendi

The court held that the mere issuance of an appointment order does not create a legal right, and the cancellation of such order without a hearing was permissible when no employment relationship was established.

Judgment Excerpts

The said Dayalbhai Dabhi died on 7th December, 1992 when he was working as a Lineman with respondent No. 1. The learned Single Judge came to the conclusion that there was no relationship of employer and employee, between the appellant and the respondent No. 1. The appellant wish to make a fresh representation for his appointment on compassionate grounds.

Procedural History

The appellant filed a petition in Special Civil Application No. 1181 of 1994, which was rejected by the learned Single Judge on 24th March, 1994, leading to the present Letters Patent Appeal.

Acts & Sections

  • Gujarat Service Rules: GSO 295, GSO 305
Subscribe to unlock full Legal Analysis Subscribe Now
Related Judgement
High Court High Court of Karnataka Allows Insurance Company's Appeal and Dismisses Claimants' Appeal in Motor Accident Claim — Compensation Reduced Due to Contributory Negligence of Deceased. Deceased motorcyclist found 50% contributory negligent for accident...
Related Judgement
Supreme Court Supreme Court Allows Appeal in Industrial Disputes Act Case — Validity of Retrenchment Compensation Upheld. The court found that the University complied with the legal requirements for retrenchment compensation under the Industrial Disputes Act, 19...