Case Note & Summary
The petitioner, Pravin Sahebrao Deshmukh, filed a writ petition before the Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench, challenging the decision of the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation (MSRTC) to not consider his Hindi Visharad qualification from Bambai Hindi Vidyapeeth as equivalent to a graduate degree for the post of Clerk-Typist (Junior). The essential qualification for the post was a graduate degree. The petitioner relied on a Government Resolution dated 28-02-2007 and a judgment of the Aurangabad Bench in Pawan Subhash Marale v. MSRTC to argue that the Hindi Visharad is equivalent to B.A. The respondents, represented by Advocate Shri Wankhede, cited the judgment of the same Court in Vijay Rai v. MSRTC, reported at 2014 I CLR 348, which held that the equivalence under the Government Resolution is only for the post of Hindi teacher, not for general posts. The Court, after hearing both sides, dismissed the petition, holding that the issue is covered by the Vijay Rai judgment and that the petitioner cannot claim equivalence for a non-teaching post. The Court did not find merit in the petitioner's reliance on the Marale judgment, as it was not shown to be applicable to the facts. The petition was dismissed with no order as to costs.
Headnote
A) Service Law - Educational Qualification - Equivalence - Hindi Visharad from Bambai Hindi Vidyapeeth - Government Resolution dated 28-02-2007 - The petitioner sought to treat Hindi Visharad as equivalent to B.A. degree for the post of Clerk-Typist. The Court held that the equivalence is only for the post of Hindi teacher, not for general graduate posts, relying on the judgment in Vijay Rai v. MSRTC. (Paras 2-6)
B) Precedent - Binding Effect - Vijay Rai v. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, 2014 I CLR 348 - The Court followed the earlier decision of the same High Court which held that the Government Resolution granting equivalence applies only to Hindi teacher posts. (Paras 5-6)
Issue of Consideration
Whether the qualification of Hindi Visharad conferred by Bambai Hindi Vidyapeeth is equivalent to a graduate degree for the purpose of eligibility for the post of Clerk-Typist (Junior) in Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation.
Final Decision
The petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Law Points
- Equivalence of qualifications
- Government Resolution interpretation
- Stare decisis
Case Details
2017 LawText (BOM) (01) 134
Writ Petition No.4556 of 2016
B.P. Dharmadhikari, Mrs. Swapna Joshi
Shri S.A. Nerkar for petitioner, Shri V.G. Wankhede for respondents
Pravin s/o Sahebrao Deshmukh
Vice-Chairman & Managing Director, Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, Mumbai and Divisional Controller, MSRTC, Amravati
Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more)
Subscribe Now
Nature of Litigation
Writ petition challenging rejection of candidature for post of Clerk-Typist (Junior) on ground of non-equivalence of Hindi Visharad qualification.
Remedy Sought
Petitioner sought direction to respondents to treat Hindi Visharad as equivalent to graduate degree and allow participation in selection process.
Filing Reason
Respondents did not consider petitioner's Hindi Visharad qualification as equivalent to graduate degree for the post of Clerk-Typist.
Previous Decisions
The High Court in Vijay Rai v. MSRTC (2014 I CLR 348) held that equivalence under Government Resolution dated 28-02-2007 is only for Hindi teacher posts.
Issues
Whether Hindi Visharad from Bambai Hindi Vidyapeeth is equivalent to a graduate degree for the post of Clerk-Typist (Junior) in MSRTC.
Submissions/Arguments
Petitioner argued that Government Resolution dated 28-02-2007 and judgment in Pawan Subhash Marale v. MSRTC support equivalence of Hindi Visharad to B.A. degree.
Respondents argued that judgment in Vijay Rai v. MSRTC (2014 I CLR 348) holds that equivalence is only for Hindi teacher posts, not for general posts.
Ratio Decidendi
The Government Resolution granting equivalence of Hindi Visharad to a graduate degree applies only to posts of Hindi teachers, not to general graduate posts like Clerk-Typist.
Judgment Excerpts
The submission of learned Advocate Shri Nerkar for the petitioner is : Qualification of Hindi Visharad conferred upon the petitioner by 'Bambai Hindi Vidyapeeth' is equivalent to B.A. degree and therefore the petitioner is entitled to participate in the selection process as a graduate person.
Learned Advocate Shri Wankhede for the respondents invites our attention to the judgment of this Court in the case of Vijay Rai vrs Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation ... reported at 2014 I CLR 348 to urge that, thereafter considering all the relevant Government Resolutions, this Court has found that the equivalence is only when the holder of such qualification applies for the post of teacher in Hindi language.
Procedural History
The petitioner filed Writ Petition No.4556 of 2016 before the Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench. The Court heard the matter finally at the stage of admission and dismissed it on 23-01-2017.
