Case Note & Summary
The petitioner, Anil Tulshiram Sonkusle, was appointed as a Junior Clerk against a Scheduled Tribe vacancy claiming Halba tribe status. He was promoted to Senior Clerk in 1992 and Head Clerk in 2000. His caste claim was invalidated by the Scrutiny Committee on 25.02.2008 based on a Police Vigilance Cell report. He challenged this in Writ Petition No.4690/2010, and a Division Bench remanded the matter for reconsideration on 19.11.2010, directing status quo until the claim is decided. Despite this, respondent no.3 issued a reversion order on 02.06.2014 reverting him to Senior Clerk for non-submission of a validity certificate. The petitioner sought quashing of this order. The court held that the reversion order was illegal as it violated the status quo direction and the matter was pending reconsideration. The court quashed the reversion order and directed the Scrutiny Committee to decide the caste claim within six months, maintaining status quo until then.
Headnote
A) Service Law - Caste Validity - Reversion During Pendency - Reversion order for non-submission of validity certificate set aside as matter was remanded for reconsideration with status quo direction - Held that reversion during pendency of reconsideration is illegal and status quo must be maintained (Paras 3-5).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the reversion order dated 02.06.2014 reverting the petitioner from Head Clerk to Senior Clerk for non-submission of caste validity certificate is sustainable when the matter was remanded for reconsideration and status quo was directed.
Final Decision
The reversion order dated 02.06.2014 is quashed and set aside. The Scrutiny Committee is directed to decide the caste claim of the petitioner within six months. Status quo as on today shall be maintained until the decision.
Law Points
- Reversion order during pendency of caste claim reconsideration is illegal
- Status quo order must be maintained until final decision
- Scrutiny Committee must decide expeditiously
Case Details
2014 LawText (BOM) (06) 98
Writ Petition No.2683/2014
Mr. S.R. Narnaware for Petitioner, Mrs. B.H. Dangre for Respondents No.1 & 3, Mr. S.M. Puranik for Respondent No.2
Anil s/o Tulshiram Sonkusle
The State of Maharashtra, Joint Commissioner & Vice-Chairman, Scheduled Tribe Caste Certificate Scrutiny Committee, Deputy Director, Sports & Youth Services
Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more)
Subscribe Now
Nature of Litigation
Writ petition challenging reversion order for non-submission of caste validity certificate.
Remedy Sought
Quashing of reversion order dated 02.06.2014 and direction to maintain status quo.
Filing Reason
Petitioner was reverted from Head Clerk to Senior Clerk despite status quo order during reconsideration of caste claim.
Previous Decisions
Caste claim invalidated on 25.02.2008; challenged in WP 4690/2010; remanded for reconsideration on 19.11.2010 with status quo direction.
Issues
Whether reversion order during pendency of caste claim reconsideration is valid.
Submissions/Arguments
Petitioner argued that reversion order violates status quo direction and is illegal.
Respondents argued that reversion was for non-submission of validity certificate.
Ratio Decidendi
A reversion order passed during the pendency of reconsideration of a caste claim, when status quo has been directed, is illegal and cannot be sustained.
Judgment Excerpts
The petitioner has approached this Court praying for quashing and setting aside the reversion order dated 02.06.2014 issued by respondent no.3.
By the impugned order dated 02.06.2014, the petitioner has been reverted to the post of Senior Clerk on the ground of non-submission of the validity certificate.
In the result, the petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 02.06.2014 is quashed and set aside.
Procedural History
Petitioner appointed as Junior Clerk against ST vacancy; promoted to Senior Clerk (1992) and Head Clerk (2000). Caste claim invalidated on 25.02.2008. Challenged in WP 4690/2010; remanded for reconsideration on 19.11.2010 with status quo. Reversion order issued on 02.06.2014. Present petition filed on 11.06.2014.
Acts & Sections
