Case Note & Summary
The judgment concerns two writ petitions filed in the High Court of Bombay at Goa, which were heard together to decide the issue of the extent of heritability of a mundkar's right in a dwelling house under the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975. The petitioners in Writ Petition No. 266 of 2008 were legal heirs of a deceased mundkar, and the petitioner in Writ Petition No. 457 of 2010 was also a legal representative. The respondents included the landlord and government authorities. The core legal issue was whether the right of a mundkar to occupy a dwelling house under Section 3 of the Act is heritable upon the death of the mundkar. The petitioners argued that the definition of 'mundkar' under Section 2(p) includes members of the family, and thus the right should pass to legal heirs. The respondents contended that the right was personal and not heritable. The court, after hearing arguments, analyzed the definitions in the Act, particularly Section 2(n) defining 'member of the family' and Section 2(p) defining 'mundkar'. The court held that the right of a mundkar in a dwelling house is heritable, as the Act's protective purpose and the inclusive definition of mundkar support the transmission of the right to legal heirs. The decision was pronounced on 18th December 2013 by a Division Bench comprising Justices B. R. Gavai and F. M. Reis, with the judgment authored by Justice F. M. Reis.
Headnote
A) Landlord-Tenant Law - Mundkar Rights - Heritability - Section 3 of Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975 - The court considered whether the right of a mundkar in a dwelling house is heritable. The court held that the right to occupy a dwelling house under Section 3 is heritable, as the definition of 'mundkar' includes family members and the Act aims to protect mundkars from eviction. (Paras 3-4)
Issue of Consideration
Whether the right of a mundkar in a dwelling house under Section 3 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975 is heritable.
Final Decision
The court held that the right of a mundkar in a dwelling house under Section 3 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975 is heritable. The petitions were disposed of in terms of this finding.
Law Points
- Heritability of mundkar rights
- Interpretation of Section 3 of Goa Mundkars Act
- 1975
- Definition of mundkar includes family members
- Right to dwelling house is heritable
Case Details
2013 LawText (BOM) (12) 112
Writ Petition Nos. 457 of 2010 and 266 of 2008
Mr. J. P. Mulgaonkar for Petitioner in WP 457/2010; Mr. Sudin Usgaonkar with Ms. A. Shirodkar for Respondents in WP 457/2010; Mr. S. D. Lotlikar, Senior Advocate with Ms. Neelam Patil for Petitioners in WP 266/2008; Mr. C. A. Coutinho for Respondent in WP 266/2008
Mrs. Henriqueta D' Souza (Deceased through legal representative Mrs. Isabel D' Souza) in WP 457/2010; Shri Rama Hegde (Deceased through legal heirs) in WP 266/2008
Shri Mangesh D. Mishal and others in WP 457/2010; Shri Diogo Piedade Rodrigues (Deceased through legal heir Smt. Maria E. Rodrigues) in WP 266/2008
Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more)
Subscribe Now
Nature of Litigation
Writ petitions challenging eviction or seeking declaration of mundkar rights under the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975.
Remedy Sought
Petitioners sought to establish that the right of a mundkar in a dwelling house is heritable and that legal heirs are entitled to protection from eviction.
Filing Reason
Dispute over whether the right of a mundkar to occupy a dwelling house under Section 3 of the Act passes to legal heirs upon death.
Issues
Whether the right of a mundkar in a dwelling house under Section 3 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975 is heritable.
Submissions/Arguments
Petitioners argued that the definition of 'mundkar' under Section 2(p) includes members of the family, and thus the right to occupy a dwelling house is heritable.
Respondents argued that the right is personal and not heritable.
Ratio Decidendi
The right of a mundkar in a dwelling house under Section 3 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975 is heritable because the definition of 'mundkar' includes family members and the Act's purpose is to protect mundkars from eviction, which extends to their legal heirs.
Judgment Excerpts
We have heard the above Petition only to decide the issue regarding the extent of heritability of a right of a mundkar in a dwelling house in terms of Section 3 of the Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975.
Shri S. D. Lotlikar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the said Petitioners, has submitted before us that a Mundkar is defined under Section 2(p) of the said Act of 1975 wherein, he also includes a member of the family.
Procedural History
The writ petitions were filed in the High Court of Bombay at Goa. They were taken up for consideration under Rule 7 Chapter 1 of the Appellate Side Rules of 1960 and placed before a Division Bench by order of the Chief Justice. The court heard arguments on 10th December 2013 and pronounced judgment on 18th December 2013.
Acts & Sections
- Goa, Daman and Diu Mundkars (Protection from Eviction) Act, 1975: Section 3, Section 2(p), Section 2(n)
