Case Note & Summary
The case involved a Letters Patent Appeal against an order of a learned Single Judge regarding the appointment and promotion of a Telephone Operator in the High Court of Gujarat. The petitioner was appointed on a temporary basis in 1973 and continued in that role, despite the post being termed temporary. The petitioner sought betterment due to stagnation and was temporarily appointed as a Section Writer in 1982, but later requested to return to his original post. The petitioner filed Special Civil Application No. 5166 of 1987, leading to a Government Resolution in 1991 aimed at addressing stagnation in service. The learned Single Judge directed the petitioner to be absorbed into the cadre of Junior Clerk and granted him special pay. The appeal primarily contested the directions regarding the grant of higher grade scales. The court analyzed the applicability of the Government Resolution dated 16-8-1994, which allowed counting service rendered in an ex-cadre post for the purpose of promotions. The court concluded that the petitioner was entitled to the first higher grade scale from the date of absorption but would have to wait for the second higher grade scale until certain conditions were met. The court ordered the implementation of the first higher grade scale within two months, with no costs awarded.
Headnote
A) Employment Law - Higher Grade Scale - Eligibility for Higher Grade Scale - Government Resolution, 1991 - The court modified the directions regarding the grant of second higher grade scale, stating that the petitioner must complete one year after reaching the maximum stage in the first higher grade or complete 18 years of service in the grade, whichever is later, as per the applicable Government Resolution. Held that the petitioner is entitled to the first higher grade scale from the date of absorption in the cadre post (Paras 7-12).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioner is entitled to the benefits of the Government Resolution regarding higher grade scales based on service rendered in an ex-cadre post.
Final Decision
The court modified the learned Single Judge's directions regarding the second higher grade scale, stating that the petitioner must complete one year after reaching the maximum stage in the first higher grade or complete 18 years of service in the grade, whichever is later. The first higher grade scale was to be granted from the date of absorption in the cadre post, and implementation was ordered within two months.
Law Points
- Government Resolutions
- Higher Grade Scale
- Cadre Inclusion
- Service Counting
- Employment Rights



