Search Results for "uncommunicated ACR entries"

Trending :

Bombay High Court Allows Appeals by Acquiring Body in Land Acquisition Compensat...
Bombay High Court Dismisses NHAI Appeals in Land Acquisition Compensation Disput...
Bombay High Court Dismisses Writ Petition Challenging Concurrent Findings in Sui...
Supreme Court Hears Appeals Against Madras High Court’s Setting Aside of Alien...
Supreme Court Hears Appeals on Permanent Establishment of Formula One World Cham...

Search Results for "uncommunicated ACR entries"

15 result(s) found

Home Search Results

Scroll Down To Discover

Found 15 result(s)

High Court

High Court Quashes Rejection of Non-Functional Selection Grade Promotion for CRPF Doctor and Orders Fresh Consideration. The court held that rejection orders were non-speaking and violated natural justice by considering uncommunicated Annual Confidential Report gradings below benchmark, under Department of Personnel and Training Office Memoranda and Dynamic Assured Career Progression scheme.

18 Mar 2026

The dispute involved a writ petition filed by Petitioner, a Chief Medical Officer in the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), challenging the rejectio...

High Court

High Court Allows Petition Challenging Adverse Remarks in Annual Confidential Reports Due to Delayed Communication - Delayed communication of ACRs violates natural justice, making adverse remarks inadmissible for promotion consideration under Government Resolution dated 31 March 1989.

19 Jan 2026

The dispute involved a petition filed by a retired Office Superintendent against the State of Gujarat and another respondent, challenging adverse rema...

High Court

Gujarat High Court Allows Promotion Claim Due to Non-Communication of APARs — IRCTC Promotion Policy Benchmark Quashed as Arbitrary. The court held that non-communication of Annual Performance Appraisal Reports before using them to deny promotion violates principles of natural justice, and directed reconsideration of promotion without considering uncommunicated APARs.

5 Jan 2026

The petitioner, Susheel Patil, an employee of Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation Ltd (IRCTC), filed a petition under Articles 14, 16 and ...

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Dismisses Appeal of Doctor Denied Promotion in Indian Railway Medical Service Due to Inadequate Grading. Selection Committee's Assessment of Annual Confidential Reports Held to Be Objective and Not Vitiated by Bias or Arbitrariness.

1 Jan 2026

The appellant, Dr. Indira Saranath, was a doctor in the Indian Railway Medical Service (IRMS). She sought promotion to the post of Chief Medical Direc...

Supreme Court

High Court Upholds Screening Committee's Decision in IAS Officer Promotion Case Due to Lack of ACRs and Unsatisfactory Performance. Promotion to Chief Secretary Grade Denied as Officer Failed to Meet Guidelines Under IAS (Pay) Rules, 2016, with Review Committee Properly Considering Adverse Remarks and Unauthorized Absence.

23 Apr 2025

The dispute involved an IAS officer of the 1991 batch in the Kerala cadre, seeking promotion to the Chief Secretary grade under the IAS (Pay) Rules, 2...

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Reinstates Two Women Judicial Officers Terminated During Probation in Madhya Pradesh — Termination Set Aside for Non-Compliance with Natural Justice and Recruitment Rules. The Court held that termination based on adverse remarks without opportunity of hearing violates Article 311 and Madhya Pradesh Judicial Service Rules, 1994.

7 Mar 2025

The Supreme Court of India adjudicated three connected matters concerning the termination of six women judicial officers (Civil Judges, Junior Divisio...

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Reinstates Premature Retirement Order of Head Constable Under Fundamental Rules and CCS (Pension) Rules. The Court Held That Judicial Review of Compulsory Retirement Is Limited to Mala Fides, Arbitrariness, or Perversity, and Entire Service Record Including Old Adverse Entries and Uncommunicated Remarks Can Be Considered.

4 Feb 2022

The appeal arose from an order of the Delhi High Court that set aside the premature retirement of a Head Constable under Rule 56(j) of the Fundamental...

Supreme Court

Supreme Court Allows Appeal in Promotion Dispute Due to Non-Communication of APAR Entries. Failure to Disclose Annual Performance Appraisal Report Entries Violates Principles of Natural Justice and Law Laid Down in Dev Dutt and Sukhdev Singh.

10 Jul 2019

The dispute arose from the appellant's claim for promotion from Scale III to Scale IV in United India Insurance Co Ltd for the year 2014-2015. The app...

High Court

Bombay High Court Allows Petition of Judicial Officer Challenging Compulsory Retirement. Non-Communication of Adverse Remarks in ACRs Violates Natural Justice, Order Set Aside.

8 Oct 2014

The petitioner, Smt. Shraddha Vinod Deo, was appointed as a Judicial Magistrate First Class on 1st September 1990 and served at various places includi...

High Court

Bombay High Court Quashes Compulsory Retirement of District Judge Due to Non-Communication of Adverse Remarks. Adverse CR Entries Without Communication Violate Principles of Natural Justice Under Rule 19 of Maharashtra Judicial Services Rules, 2008.

16 Nov 2011

The petitioner, a judicial officer, challenged an order dated 26 February 2010 passed by the Principal Secretary and Legal Advisor, Law and Justice De...

1 2

Full Name * Username * Mobile Number * Email Address * State/UT * City * Password * Confirm Password * Referral Code (Optional)