WRIT PETITION NO.4761 OF 2024
19 Jun 2025...
Search Results for "irrationality"
318 result(s) found
Found 318 result(s)
High Court
Bombay High Court Quashes Tender Condition in Food Kit Supply RFP for Gauri Ganpati Festival — Condition Held Arbitrary and Unreasonable. Pre-qualification criterion requiring experience of providing 300 labourers in 70 government locations with Rs. 25 crore work order found to be irrational and tailored to exclude eligible bidders.
5 Aug 2024The Bombay High Court, in a batch of writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution, challenged a pre-qualification condition (PQ5) in a Request...
- 295
High Court
High Court of Bombay at Nagpur Quashes Rejection of Techno-Commercial Bid in Tender Matter — Petitioner's Bid Rejected Due to Encumbrance on Leased Land, Court Finds Rejection Arbitrary and Directs Reconsideration
18 Mar 2024The petitioner, Tara Chand Infralogistic Solutions Limited, challenged the rejection of its techno-commercial bid submitted in response to a Notice In...
- 44
High Court
Bombay High Court Allows Petitioners in Tender Exclusion Case Due to Non-Application of Mind by State. Exclusion from tender for school uniform cloth procurement set aside as evaluation committee failed to consider petitioners' compliance with technical specifications.
12 Mar 2024The petitioners, Kanchan India Limited and Arvind Cotsyn India Limited, challenged their exclusion from a tender process issued by the Government of M...
- 44
Supreme Court
Supreme Court Dismisses Appeals Challenging DGP Appointment in Punjab, Upholds UPSC Selection Process. Appointment Valid as Empanelment Followed Supreme Court Directions in Prakash Singh Case and Draft Guidelines, with No Proven Bias or Arbitrariness.
16 Nov 2021The dispute arose from the appointment of Mr. Dinkar Gupta as Director General of Police (Head of Police Force) for Punjab in 2019, challenged by appe...
- 606
Supreme Court
Supreme Court Allows Appeals in Coal Mines (Special Provisions) Act Case, Overturning High Court's Grant of First Right of Refusal. The Court Held That Section 11 of the Act Does Not Confer a First Right of Refusal and Upheld the Competitive Bidding Process for Appointing a Mine Developer-cum-Operator.
21 Sep 2021The Supreme Court of India heard civil appeals arising from special leave petitions concerning a dispute over the interpretation of Section 11 of the ...
- 395
Supreme Court
Supreme Court Allows Appeal by Cooperative Federation on Pay Scale Revision Date Due to Financial Constraints. The Court Held That Financial Stringency Is a Valid Consideration for Deferring Implementation of Revised Pay Scales Under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and Service Rules, Overturning the High Court's Finding of Unfairness.
9 Jul 2021The Supreme Court of India heard civil appeals filed by the Punjab State Co-operative Milk Producers Federation Ltd. against a High Court order that a...
- 597
Supreme Court
Supreme Court Dismisses Tender Dispute Petition, Upholds Limited Judicial Review in Government Contracts. The Court held that writ courts should not interfere in commercial decisions of public sector undertakings unless arbitrariness, mala fides, or perversity is established, and that the employer is the best judge of tender conditions.
21 Jun 2019The case involves a dispute over the rejection of a tender submitted by The Silppi Constructions Contractors (the petitioner) for two works at Kochi, ...
- 237
High Court
Bombay High Court Upholds Externment Orders Under Maharashtra Police Act — Clarifies Conditions for Section 56(1)(a) and (b) and Requirement of Witness Fear. The court held that each clause has distinct requirements and the authority must apply mind to proportionality and natural justice.
8 Feb 2019The judgment concerns three criminal writ petitions challenging externment orders passed under Section 56(1)(a) and (b) of the Maharashtra Police Act,...
- 109
High Court
Bombay High Court Upholds Externment Orders Under Section 56(1)(a) and (b) of Maharashtra Police Act, 1951 — Emphasizes Need for Application of Mind and Compliance with Audi Alteram Partem. Court Holds That Externment Orders Must Be Based on Subjective Satisfaction of the Authority and Not Be Excessive or Arbitrary.
8 Feb 2019The judgment arises from three criminal writ petitions challenging externment orders passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Nagpur, under Sectio...
- 109
