Supreme Court Dismisses Appeal in Disciplinary Proceedings Case — Obligation of Governor to Grant Request for Tribunal Enquiry Established. The court held that the word 'may' in Rule 4(2) imposes an obligation on the Governor to grant a request made by a gazetted government servant for an enquiry by the Tribunal.

  • 3
Judgement Image
Font size:
Print

Case Note & Summary

The case involved a dispute regarding the disciplinary proceedings against a Naib Tehsildar, Jogendra Singh, appointed by the State of Uttar Pradesh in 1937. He was suspended on August 4, 1952, due to complaints against him, and an enquiry was initiated by the Administrative Tribunal, which exonerated him in August 1953. However, additional complaints led to his suspension again on October 28, 1956, and the case was referred to the Commissioner for disciplinary proceedings, despite his request for the enquiry to be conducted by the Administrative Tribunal. The High Court ruled in favor of Singh, stating that as a gazetted officer, he was entitled to have his case referred to the Tribunal, leading to the appellant's appeal to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court examined the construction of Rule 4(2) of the Uttar Pradesh Disciplinary Proceedings (Administrative Tribunal) Rules, 1947, specifically whether the word 'may' conferred discretion or imposed an obligation. The court concluded that the purpose of Rule 4(2) would be frustrated if 'may' was interpreted as discretionary, thus establishing that the Governor was obliged to grant the request for a Tribunal enquiry. The appeal was dismissed with costs, affirming the High Court's decision. The ruling clarified the obligations of the Governor concerning disciplinary proceedings for gazetted government servants.

Headnote

A) Administrative Law - Disciplinary Proceedings - Construction of 'may' in Rule 4(2) - Uttar Pradesh Disciplinary Proceedings (Administrative Tribunal) Rules, 1947, Rule 4(2) - The court held that the word 'may' in Rule 4(2) imposes an obligation on the Governor to grant a request made by a gazetted government servant for an enquiry by the Tribunal, distinguishing it from the discretionary 'may' in Rule 4(1). The High Court's decision to quash the proceedings against the respondent was upheld as the request for a Tribunal enquiry was not granted. (Paras 196-203).

Subscribe to unlock Headnote Subscribe Now

Issue of Consideration

Whether the word 'may' in Rule 4(2) of the Uttar Pradesh Disciplinary Proceedings (Administrative Tribunal) Rules, 1947 confers discretion on the Governor or imposes an obligation to grant a request for enquiry by the Tribunal.

Subscribe to unlock Issue of Consideration Subscribe Now

Final Decision

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, concluding that the Governor was obliged to grant the request for an enquiry by the Administrative Tribunal under Rule 4(2). The proceedings against the respondent were quashed.

Law Points

  • Disciplinary proceedings
  • construction of rules
  • discretion of Governor
  • gazetted government servants
  • Administrative Tribunal
Subscribe to unlock Law Points Subscribe Now

Case Details

Civil Appeal No. 301 of 1961

1964-03-04

P. B. Gajendragadkar, M. Hidayatullah, J. C. Shah

K. S. Hajela, C. P. Lal, K. L. Gosain, Saunit Lal

State of Uttar Pradesh

Jogendra Singh

Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more) Subscribe Now

Nature of Litigation

Disciplinary proceedings against a government servant

Remedy Sought

The respondent sought to quash the disciplinary proceedings and have the enquiry conducted by the Administrative Tribunal.

Filing Reason

The respondent's request for an enquiry by the Tribunal was rejected by the Governor.

Previous Decisions

The High Court quashed the order directing the enquiry to be held by the appointed authority.

Issues

Construction of 'may' in Rule 4(2) Obligation of the Governor regarding requests for Tribunal enquiry

Submissions/Arguments

The appellant argued that the Governor had discretion under Rule 4(2). The respondent contended that the Governor was obliged to grant the request for a Tribunal enquiry.

Ratio Decidendi

The court established that the word 'may' in Rule 4(2) of the Uttar Pradesh Disciplinary Proceedings (Administrative Tribunal) Rules, 1947 imposes an obligation on the Governor to grant a request for an enquiry by the Tribunal, distinguishing it from the discretionary nature of 'may' in Rule 4(1).

Judgment Excerpts

The whole purpose of rule 4(2) would be frustrated if the word 'may' in the said rule receives the same construction as in sub-rule (1). The plain and unambiguous object of enacting rule 4(2) is to provide an option to the gazetted government servants to request the Governor that their cases should be tried by a Tribunal.

Procedural History

The respondent was suspended and faced disciplinary proceedings initiated by the appellant. After being exonerated by the Administrative Tribunal, additional complaints led to further suspension and a request for an enquiry by the Tribunal was rejected. The respondent filed a writ petition in the High Court, which was allowed, leading to the appellant's appeal to the Supreme Court.

Acts & Sections

  • Uttar Pradesh Disciplinary Proceedings (Administrative Tribunal) Rules: Rule 4(1), Rule 4(2)
Subscribe to unlock full Legal Analysis Subscribe Now
Related Judgement
Supreme Court Supreme Court Invalidates Arbitration Agreement Due to Unlawful Consideration. The arbitration agreement was found invalid as it was based on the promise to withdraw a criminal complaint involving non-compoundable offences, violating public policy un...
Related Judgement
High Court Bombay High Court Dismisses Petition Challenging Income Tax Reassessment Notices Under Section 148 of Income Tax Act, 1961 — No Jurisdictional Error Found in Reopening of Assessment Beyond Four Years.