Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a civil suit filed by the petitioner against the respondents seeking a permanent injunction to prevent construction over a public road. The petitioner alleged that the respondents were encroaching upon a 30 ft. wide road adjacent to their plots. The trial court had appointed a commissioner to assess the situation, and the commissioner submitted a report. The petitioner filed objections to this report, which were scheduled for hearing. Subsequently, the petitioner sought the appointment of a second commissioner, claiming that the first had not measured the plots accurately. The trial court rejected this application without considering the pending objections. The High Court found that the trial court acted with material irregularity by not addressing the objections before deciding on the second commissioner's appointment. The court emphasized that a second commissioner cannot be appointed unless the first report is set aside. Consequently, the High Court quashed the trial court's order and directed it to first resolve the objections raised by the petitioner before considering any further applications for a commissioner. The revision application was allowed, and the trial court was instructed to proceed accordingly.
Headnote
A) Civil Procedure - Appointment of Commissioner - Jurisdictional Error - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, Section 115 - The trial court failed to consider the plaintiff's objections against the first commissioner's report before rejecting the application for a second commissioner. The court held that the appointment of a second commissioner is not permissible unless the first commissioner's report is set aside, necessitating a review of the objections filed by the plaintiff. Held that the trial court must first address the objections before considering any further applications (Paras 5-7).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the trial court erred in rejecting the application for appointment of a second commissioner without considering the plaintiff's objections to the first commissioner's report.
Final Decision
The High Court allowed the civil revision application, quashed the trial court's order dated 20.7.1996, and directed the trial court to hear and decide the objections filed by the petitioner against the first commissioner's report before considering any application for a second commissioner.
Law Points
- Civil Procedure
- appointment of commissioner
- objections to commissioner report
- jurisdictional error


