Supreme Court Invalidates Security Requirement in Writ Petitions — Rule Found Unconstitutional for Hindering Access to Justice. The Court held that imposing a financial burden on petitioners under Article 32 contravenes their fundamental rights.

  • 1
Judgement Image
Font size:
Print

Case Note & Summary

The case involved a writ petition filed under Article 32 of the Constitution by Prem Chand Garg and others, challenging the validity of an order by the Excise Commissioner of U.P. The Supreme Court was asked to determine the validity of Rule 12 of Order XXXV of the Supreme Court Rules, which required petitioners to furnish security for the costs of the respondents. The petitioners argued that this rule was unconstitutional as it impeded their fundamental right to seek enforcement of their rights under Article 32. The Court analyzed the implications of the rule, noting that while the right to move the Supreme Court is not absolute, it cannot be subjected to financial conditions that would deter individuals from asserting their rights. The Court held that the requirement for security for costs was invalid as it effectively barred access to justice for those unable to pay. The judgment underscored the importance of protecting fundamental rights and declared that any procedural rule that obstructs this right must be invalidated. The Court ultimately ruled in favor of the petitioners, striking down the impugned rule as unconstitutional.

Headnote

A) Constitutional Law - Fundamental Rights - Right to Move Supreme Court - Article 32 - The right to move the Supreme Court under Article 32 is an absolute right and cannot be impaired by any rule requiring security for costs. The Court held that such a requirement contravenes the fundamental right guaranteed under Article 32, as it obstructs the assertion of this right. (Paras 1-5)

B) Supreme Court Rules - Validity of Rule 12 - Rule 12 of Order XXXV is invalid as it imposes a financial burden on petitioners, which can hinder their ability to seek justice under Article 32. The Court emphasized that any rule that obstructs the assertion of fundamental rights must be struck down. (Paras 6-10)

Subscribe to unlock Headnote Subscribe Now

Issue of Consideration

Whether Rule 12 of Order XXXV of the Supreme Court Rules, which requires security for costs in writ petitions under Article 32, is valid.

Subscribe to unlock Issue of Consideration Subscribe Now

Final Decision

The Supreme Court held that Rule 12 of Order XXXV of the Supreme Court Rules is invalid as it requires security for costs, which contravenes the fundamental right to move the Supreme Court under Article 32. The Court emphasized that such a requirement impedes access to justice and must be struck down.

Law Points

  • Fundamental rights
  • Article 32
  • Security for costs
  • Supreme Court Rules
  • Article 145
Subscribe to unlock Law Points Subscribe Now

Case Details

Writ Petition No. 52 of 1962

1962-11-06

B. P. Sinha, P. B. Gajendragadkar, K. N. Wanchoo, K. C. Das Gupta, J. C. Shah

G. S. Pathak, R. Gopalakrishnan, Naunit Lal, K. S. Hajek, O. P. Lal, O. K. Dapktary, B. R. L. Iyengar, R. H. Dikebar

Prem Chand Garg and others

Excise Commissioner, U.P.

Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more) Subscribe Now

Nature of Litigation

Writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution

Remedy Sought

Petitioners sought to challenge the requirement of security for costs imposed by the Supreme Court

Filing Reason

The petitioners contended that the rule contravened their fundamental rights

Previous Decisions

The Supreme Court had previously dealt with similar issues regarding the enforcement of fundamental rights

Issues

Validity of Rule 12 of Order XXXV Impact of security for costs on access to justice

Submissions/Arguments

Petitioners argued that the rule obstructs their fundamental right under Article 32 Respondents contended that the rule is discretionary and does not violate Article 32

Ratio Decidendi

The right to move the Supreme Court under Article 32 is absolute and cannot be conditioned upon the payment of costs, as this would infringe upon the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution.

Judgment Excerpts

The right to move the Supreme Court under Art. 32 is an absolute right and the content of this right cannot be circumscribed or impaired on any ground. An order for furnishing security for the respondent's costs retards the assertion or vindication of the fundamental right under Art. 32 and contravenes the said right.

Procedural History

The petition was filed under Article 32 challenging the validity of an order by the Excise Commissioner. The Supreme Court admitted the petition and issued a rule, requiring the petitioners to furnish security for costs, which led to the current challenge.

Acts & Sections

  • Constitution of India: Article 32, Article 145
  • Supreme Court Rules: Order XXXV, Rule 12
Subscribe to unlock full Legal Analysis Subscribe Now
Related Judgement
Supreme Court Supreme Court Upholds Appellant's Challenge to Jurisdiction in Arbitration Matter — Jurisdiction Determined by Cause of Action Location.
Related Judgement
Supreme Court Supreme Court Dismisses Appeals Regarding Seniority in Public Works Department Due to Delay in Grievance. Delay in Raising Seniority Issue Found to Be Laches, Affecting Rights of Other Employees.