Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the expulsion of the appellant from Lodge Victoria No. 363, a Daughter Lodge under the Grand Lodge of Scotland. The appellant was accused of committing 12 masonic offences, leading to disciplinary proceedings initiated by the Lodge. Following a special meeting where the charges were discussed and voted upon, the appellant was found guilty and expelled, pending confirmation from the District Grand Lodge. The appellant appealed to the District Grand Lodge and subsequently to the Grand Lodge of Scotland, both of which upheld the expulsion. Dissatisfied, the appellant filed a suit in the Civil Court seeking a declaration that the expulsion was void. The Civil Judge dismissed the suit, and the High Court of Mysore also dismissed the appeal. The Supreme Court was approached on a certificate from the High Court. The appellant contended that the Daughter Lodge lacked jurisdiction to try the offences and that the disciplinary procedures were not followed strictly, particularly regarding the notice period. The Supreme Court held that the Daughter Lodge had the jurisdiction to expel members for masonic offences as per its rules. It emphasized that the rules must be strictly adhered to, but minor deviations do not invalidate proceedings unless they cause prejudice. The court found that the appellant had waived his right to object to the notice period by not raising it in earlier appeals. The court also ruled that the principles of natural justice were not violated as the appellant did not raise any objections during the proceedings. Ultimately, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the decisions of the lower courts.
Headnote
A) Masonic Law - Jurisdiction of Daughter Lodge - Power to Expel Members - Full Act Name Not Mentioned - The Daughter Lodge has jurisdiction to try a member for masonic offences as per its rules, and the expulsion must follow the prescribed procedures. The court held that the Daughter Lodge acted within its jurisdiction and complied with the necessary rules for expulsion (Paras 1-2). B) Compliance with Rules - Strict Adherence Required - Full Act Name Not Mentioned - The rules governing expulsion must be strictly followed, and any deviation must be substantial to invalidate the proceedings. The court found that the appellant waived his right to object to procedural defects by not raising them in prior appeals (Paras 3-4). C) Natural Justice - Application in Domestic Tribunals - Full Act Name Not Mentioned - The principles of natural justice apply, but the court noted that the appellant did not raise objections during the proceedings, thus the resolution was not invalidated on these grounds. The court emphasized that civil courts cannot review the merits of decisions made by domestic tribunals (Paras 5-6).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the Daughter Lodge had jurisdiction to expel the appellant and whether the disciplinary proceedings complied with the rules.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the decisions of the lower courts. It held that the Daughter Lodge had jurisdiction to expel the appellant and that the rules were complied with sufficiently.
Law Points
- jurisdiction of civil courts
- expulsion from membership
- compliance with rules
- principles of natural justice
- domestic tribunal powers



