Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose in Suit No. 937 of 1981, where Dr. Narayan Kisanlal Malpani and others were the plaintiffs against M/s. Jamshedji Rustomji Devidas and Jani & Merchants as defendants. The case involved the submission of additional documents by the defendants during the ongoing proceedings, where a commissioner had already been appointed to record evidence. The defendants' counsel sought to file a compilation of additional documents, to which the plaintiffs' counsel raised an objection regarding one specific document, an article published in the Times of India. The court allowed the submission of all documents except the contested one, emphasizing that the defendants could prove their documents in accordance with the law after the commissioner's report was submitted. The court's decision underscored the importance of following procedural norms while ensuring that the defendants had the opportunity to present their case effectively. The judgment was delivered by Justice V.M. Kanade on 17th September 2008.
Headnote
A) Civil Procedure - Admissibility of Documents - Additional Documents Submission - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - The court allowed the defendants to submit additional documents for consideration, except for one document objected to by the plaintiffs. The court directed the commissioner to proceed with recording evidence and submit a report, granting liberty to the defendants to prove the documents after the report is submitted. Held that the process must adhere to legal standards (Paras 1-1).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the additional documents submitted by the defendants can be admitted into evidence.
Final Decision
The court allowed the defendants to submit additional documents except for one objected to by the plaintiffs, directing the commissioner to proceed with recording evidence and submit a report.
Law Points
- Civil procedure
- admissibility of documents
- role of commissioner



