Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose in the context of property sales involving multiple suits filed in the High Court of Judicature at Bombay. The plaintiffs in the suits included Ashok Thaper & Ors. and Mr. Dharmendra Kumar Goyal, while the defendants were M/s. Shantivan Developers Pvt. Ltd. and Rajdhani Properties Pvt. Ltd. The court convened to address offers made for the purchase of a property, with Mr. Narula representing the judgment-debtor, who indicated the potential for a higher offer than that of M/s. Raja Food Products Ltd. The judgment-debtor's representative stated that they had parties willing to offer 15% more than the current offer of Rs. 1,11,00,000. A demand draft for Rs. 25,00,000 was submitted as earnest money, contingent upon court sanction. The court noted that if the judgment-debtor failed to present a higher offer within a week, the existing offer from M/s. Raja Food Products Ltd. would be considered. Additionally, the court addressed concerns regarding the auction advertisement, which did not include the value of a terrace abutting the flats. Both parties indicated they would adjust their offers to account for this terrace. The court set a subsequent date for consideration of the offers.
Headnote
A) Civil Procedure - Property Sale - Consideration of Offers - Not applicable - The court considered offers for the purchase of property, with the judgment-debtor stating they could present a higher offer than the current one. The court directed that if no higher offer was made within a week, the matter would be placed on board for considering the existing offer. Held that the judgment-debtor must act promptly to secure a better offer (Paras 1-2).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the judgment-debtor can present a higher offer for the property than the current offer made by M/s. Raja Food Products Ltd.
Final Decision
The court directed that if the judgment-debtor fails to present a higher offer within a week, the matter would be placed on board for considering the existing offer from M/s. Raja Food Products Ltd.
Law Points
- Civil procedure
- property sale
- earnest money
- auction advertisement
- court receiver's role



