Case Note & Summary
The case involved an appeal regarding the presumption of a lost grant related to land possession. The appellant, the Mahant of Rajgunj Asthal, sought to recover possession of land occupied by the defendants or alternatively, for the assessment of fair rent. The appellant claimed that the land was part of a permanent Mokarrari grant made over 200 years ago by the Maharaja of Burdwan, while the defendants contended that the land was granted as Lakheraj to their predecessors before the permanent settlement. The District Munsif ruled in favor of the appellant, but the District Judge and subsequently the High Court dismissed the appeal, presuming a lost grant in favor of the defendants based on their long possession without payment of rent. The Supreme Court was tasked with determining the correctness of this presumption. The court noted that a presumption of lost grant could arise only under specific conditions, including continuous possession without challenge. However, it found that the defendants had denied the title of the Maharaja and the Asthal, thus negating their claim to a lost grant from those entities. The court also highlighted that the defendants had not established their possession as adverse prior to 1931, when the record of rights was published. Consequently, the court restored the decrees of the District Munsif, allowing the appellant's claim for fair rent and rejecting the defendants' arguments regarding limitation and adverse possession. The appeals were allowed with costs awarded to the appellant.
Headnote
A) Property Law - Presumption of Lost Grant - Conditions for Presumption - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - A presumption of a lost grant arises when a person proves ancient and continued possession without challenge, but it is not irrebuttable. The court held that the presumption could not be made due to the legal incompetence of the Mohunt to grant Niskar and the absence of proof of adverse title prior to 1931 (Paras 1172-1173). B) Limitation Law - Limitation for Recovery of Rent - Limitation Act, 1963, Article 131 - The suits were held to be within time as they were filed within 12 years of the final settlement of records published in 1931. The court rejected the plea of adverse possession as it was not raised in the lower courts (Paras 1176-1177).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the courts below were correct in presuming a lost grant in favor of the defendants.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals, set aside the decrees of the District Court and High Court, and restored the decrees of the District Munsif with costs.
Law Points
- Presumption of lost grant
- ancient possession
- legal origin of possession
- adverse possession
- Limitation Act



