High Court of Uttarakhand Disposes Writ Petitions for Police Personnel Relocation. Court directed the Advisory Committee to consider representations of police personnel for transfer to Uttar Pradesh. The court emphasized the right to be heard as a principle of natural justice under Section 73 of the Uttar Pradesh Reorganization Act, 2000.

  • 4
Judgement Image
Font size:
Print

Case Note & Summary

The case involved multiple writ petitions filed by police personnel seeking relief to be transferred from the State of Uttaranchal to Uttar Pradesh. The petitioners, comprising Constables, Head Constables, and Sub Inspectors, claimed that their options for relocation had not been considered by the Advisory Committee established under the Uttar Pradesh Reorganization Act, 2000. They argued that the Central Government had failed to frame a policy for final allocation, resulting in their continued suffering due to inaction. The court examined the provisions of Section 73 of the Act, which mandates provisional service and final allocation by the Central Government. It noted that the Advisory Committee was constituted to assist in ensuring fair treatment and consideration of representations. The court referenced previous decisions indicating that the final allocation of personnel was the responsibility of the Central Government and that the petitioners' claims were premature until such decisions were made. However, the court also recognized the petitioners' right to be heard, citing the principle of natural justice. It directed the petitioners to submit their representations to the Advisory Committee, which was required to consider these within six weeks. The court disposed of the writ petitions without costs, affirming the necessity of due process in administrative decisions affecting the petitioners.

Headnote

A) Administrative Law - Writ of Mandamus - Relief for Police Personnel - Uttar Pradesh Reorganization Act, 2000, Section 73 - Petitioners sought relief to be transferred to Uttar Pradesh as their options were not considered by the Advisory Committee. The court directed the Advisory Committee to consider the representations of the petitioners within six weeks, emphasizing the right to be heard as a principle of natural justice. Held that the petitioners should be given an opportunity to present their case (Paras 18-18).

Subscribe to unlock Headnote Subscribe Now

Issue of Consideration

Whether the petitioners are entitled to be relieved from Uttaranchal to Uttar Pradesh based on their submitted options.

Subscribe to unlock Issue of Consideration Subscribe Now

Final Decision

The court directed the petitioners to approach the Advisory Committee for consideration of their representations regarding transfer to Uttar Pradesh, to be disposed of within six weeks. The writ petitions were disposed of without costs.

Law Points

  • mandamus
  • natural justice
  • advisory committee
  • final allocation
  • Uttar Pradesh Reorganization Act
  • 2000
Subscribe to unlock Law Points Subscribe Now

Case Details

W.P. No. 924 of 2001 (SS)

2003-11-18

Rajesh Tandon

Sri C. K. Sharma, Sri Chhitij Sharma, Smt. Beena Pandey, Sri Rakesh Thapliyal

Brijbeer Singh & 3 others, Tarun Pratap & 25 others, Chandra Pal Singh Yadav & 3 others, Ansar Khan & 15 others, Jaggivan Ram & 8 others, Ram Awatar & 18 others, Dharm Dass & 18 others, Ravindra Kumar & 22 others, Bhudev Saraswat & 18 others, Rajkumar Singh & 5 others, Girish Chandra Morya & 5 others, Lallu Singh Morya, Raj Kumar Singh & 5 others, Jagat Singh & 34 others, Subhas Chandra & 8 others, Nafis Ahmad & 20 others

Union of India & others, State of Uttaranchal and others

Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more) Subscribe Now

Nature of Litigation

Writ petitions for transfer of police personnel

Remedy Sought

Relief to be transferred to Uttar Pradesh

Filing Reason

Options for transfer not considered by the Advisory Committee

Previous Decisions

Previous orders indicated that final allocation was pending

Issues

Entitlement to be relieved to Uttar Pradesh Consideration of options by the Advisory Committee

Submissions/Arguments

Petitioners argued for consideration of their options Respondents indicated that the Advisory Committee was taking steps for allocation

Ratio Decidendi

The court emphasized the right to be heard as a fundamental principle of natural justice, mandating that the Advisory Committee consider the representations of the petitioners regarding their transfer options.

Judgment Excerpts

The representations along with options shall be considered by the advisory committee of the Union of India for relieving the petitioners for the State of U.P. The apprehension is misconceived. Suffice it to state that it is rule of natural justice that no one should be condemned unheard.

Procedural History

Multiple writ petitions filed for transfer of police personnel; court heard arguments and issued directions regarding the Advisory Committee's consideration of options.

Acts & Sections

  • Uttar Pradesh Reorganization Act, 2000: Section 73, Section 76, Section 77
Subscribe to unlock full Legal Analysis Subscribe Now
Related Judgement
Supreme Court Supreme Court Remits Case for Fresh Consideration on Merits Due to Erroneous Appellate Findings. High Court's Oversight in Correlating Properties with Will Necessitates Reassessment of Title and Ownership.
Related Judgement
High Court Bombay High Court Allows Petition Challenging Co-operative Society's Bye-law Amendment for Lack of Quorum. Amendment to Bye-law 26(c) set aside as meeting lacked quorum under Section 75 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.