Case Note & Summary
The complaint was filed before the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission by a partnership firm engaged in manufacturing besan and chana dal. The firm had obtained a Standard Fire Policy from New India Assurance Company Ltd. covering its factory building, plant, machinery, and stocks, with a sum assured of Rs. 5 crores (Rs. 1.5 crores for stocks). The policy was effective from 16.09.2011 to 15.09.2012. On the night of 26.10.2011, a fire broke out inside the factory, apparently due to firecrackers during Diwali. The complainant claimed that 2470 quintals of raw grams and 3000 quintals of churi were stored and destroyed. The fire brigade was called, but the fire continued for days. The complainant lodged a claim of Rs. 1,40,20,455 with the insurer on 20.12.2011. The insurer appointed a surveyor (S. Soni & Co.) and an investigator (Royal Associates). Based on their reports, the claim was repudiated on 06.08.2012. The repudiation cited violation of policy conditions 1, 6, and 8; discrepancies in the insured's statements regarding the cause and timing of fire; lack of cooperation; inability to provide employee records and electricity bills; test results suggesting ash contained excess dust; and observations that the godown was not fully utilized and that stock may not have been present. The complainant then approached the NCDRC seeking relief. The Commission heard arguments from both sides. The judgment text is incomplete and does not contain the final order or reasoning of the Commission.
Headnote
A) Insurance Law - Fire Insurance - Standard Fire Policy - Claim Repudiation - The insurer repudiated the claim for fire loss alleging violation of policy conditions 1, 6, and 8, discrepancies in the insured's statements regarding the cause and timing of fire, absence of documentary evidence for factory operations and stock, and adverse findings in the surveyor and investigator reports. The matter was heard by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission. (Not mentioned)
Issue of Consideration
Whether the repudiation of the insurance claim by the insurer was justified under the Standard Fire Policy.
Law Points
- breach of policy conditions
- repudiation of claim
- fire insurance
- surveyor report
- investigator report
- inconsistencies in insured's statements
- cause of fire doubtful
.png)
