Case Note & Summary
The Bombay High Court, in this judgment, examined the rights of flat purchasers to obtain deemed membership in a co-operative housing society under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, despite non-payment of the entire consideration amount and pendency of a civil suit concerning the agreement for sale.The petitioners had entered into a registered agreement for sale dated 16 September 2013 with the developers. A rectification deed was subsequently executed on 5 March 2014. The petitioners applied for membership of the respondent society on 29 November 2021. As the society failed to communicate any decision or reasons, they approached the Registrar under Section 22(2) of the MCS Act.By an order dated 18 August 2022, deemed membership was granted to the petitioners. Subsequently, an authorised officer was appointed under Section 79(2)(b) to implement the order. However, the developers challenged the grant of deemed membership before the Divisional Joint Registrar, who set aside the original order on 25 November 2024, primarily on the ground that a civil suit seeking enforcement of the agreement for sale was pending.The High Court considered three principal issues.First, regarding jurisdiction, the Court held that the State Government Notification dated 8 October 2024 transferred the appellate powers under Sections 152 and 154 of the MCS Act to the Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies (SRA), Mumbai. The transfer took effect from the date of notification itself. The fact that the newly designated office became operational only in February–March 2025 could not preserve the jurisdiction of the earlier authority.The Court distinguished the Supreme Court decision in Lal Shah Baba Dargah Trust v. Magnum Developers, holding that the present case involved an actual statutory transfer of jurisdiction rather than a situation where a newly contemplated tribunal had not yet been constituted.Second, the Court examined whether the petitioners could be treated as persons who had 'taken' flats under MOFA. It observed that the registered agreement for sale was executed in Form No. 5 under Section 4 of MOFA. Such an agreement creates enforceable statutory rights in favour of flat purchasers, including rights relating to the formation and membership of a co-operative housing society.The Court held that non-payment of the balance consideration does not deprive a purchaser of the right to claim membership. The developer may pursue appropriate remedies for recovery of outstanding consideration under Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, but cannot use unpaid dues to obstruct the purchaser's membership.Third, the Court considered the effect of the pending civil suit. It held that membership determination under the MCS Act is provisional and does not amount to a final adjudication of ownership or title. Mere pendency of a civil suit does not automatically prevent the Registrar from granting deemed membership. In the absence of an injunction or restraining order from the civil court, the membership proceedings can continue, subject to the outcome of the civil suit.Accordingly, the High Court allowed the writ petition, quashed the revisional order dated 25 November 2024 and restored the Registrar's original order dated 18 August 2022 granting deemed membership to the petitioners in respect of Unit No. 601.The pending civil suit was directed to proceed independently and uninfluenced by the observations made in the judgment.
Headnote
MAHARASHTRA CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT, 1960
Sections 22(2), 79(2)(b), 152 and 154 – Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963 – Sections 4 and 10 – Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – Section 55 – Deemed membership of co-operative housing society – Rights of flat purchasers under registered agreement for sale – Whether unpaid balance consideration disentitles purchaser from obtaining society membership – Held, no – Petitioners had entered into a registered agreement for sale in Form No. 5 under Section 4 of MOFA and had applied for membership of the co-operative housing society – A purchaser under a valid registered MOFA agreement is a person who has 'taken' a flat for the purpose of claiming membership – Non-payment of balance consideration does not extinguish the purchaser's statutory right to membership – Developer's remedy lies in recovery of outstanding consideration under applicable property law – Developer cannot use unpaid dues as a ground to obstruct the purchaser's membership rights.
Civil Suit – Pendency of proceedings – Effect on deemed membership – Mere pendency of a civil suit seeking enforcement of an agreement for sale does not automatically bar the conferment of deemed membership under Section 22(2) of the MCS Act – Membership determination is provisional and does not finally adjudicate ownership or title – In the absence of an injunction or restraining order passed by the civil court, the Registrar can exercise jurisdiction to determine membership, subject to the outcome of the civil suit.
Jurisdiction of Revisional Authority – Government Notification dated 8 October 2024 – Notification issued under Section 3 of the MCS Act transferring appellate powers under Sections 152 and 154 to the Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies (SRA), Mumbai – Transfer of jurisdiction takes effect from the date of notification – Earlier authority ceases to exercise such jurisdiction from that date, irrespective of whether the newly constituted office has commenced physical functioning – Distinction drawn from Lal Shah Baba Dargah Trust v. Magnum Developers, (2015) 17 SCC 65.
Writ Petition Allowed – Impugned revisional order dated 25 November 2024 quashed and set aside – Original order granting deemed membership dated 18 August 2022 restored.
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioners were entitled to deemed membership of the co-operative housing society under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, on the basis of a registered agreement for sale under MOFA, notwithstanding the non-payment of the entire sale consideration, pendency of the civil suit and the subsequent transfer of revisional jurisdiction under the State Government Notification dated 8 October 2024?
Final Decision
The writ petition was allowed. The impugned judgment and order dated 25 November 2024 passed by the Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Mumbai Division, in Revision Application No. 409 of 2024 was quashed and set aside. Consequently, the Registrar's order dated 18 August 2022 granting deemed membership to petitioner No. 1 in respect of Unit No. 601 under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, was restored. The pending civil suit, being S.C. Suit No. 2225 of 2016, was directed to proceed in accordance with law, uninfluenced by the observations made in the present judgment. No order as to costs. The prayer for stay of the judgment was rejected.
Law Points
- Jurisdiction of revisional authority under Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act
- 1960 -- Interpretation of 'taken' under Section 4 of Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act
- 1963 -- Rights of purchasers under MOFA agreement -- Powers of Registrar under Sections 152 and 154 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act -- Effect of government notification on jurisdiction
Case Details
2026 LawText (BOM) (01) 57
Writ Petition No. 13583 of 2025
Mr. Simil Purohit, Sr. Advocate with Yogi Joshi, Sachin Mandlik, Tanay Musale i/by Mandlik & Partners for petitioners, Mr. Ashish Kamat, Sr. Advocate with Simantini, Anil R. Mishra for respondent Nos. 1 & 2, Mr. Abhishek C. Bhadang, AGP for State – respondent No. 3, Ms. Priyanka Bhadrashete for respondent No. 4
Digant Parekh (HUF) through its Karta Mr. Digant Parekh, Mr. Digant Parekh
Akruti Kailash Construction, Wellgroomed Venture, Divisional Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Mumbai Division, Assistant Registrar, Co-operative Societies (SRA), Mr. Anand Patil, Hubtown Viva Premises Co-operative Housing Society Ltd.
Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more)
Subscribe Now
Nature of Litigation
Civil – Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging the revisional order setting aside deemed membership of a co-operative housing society under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
Remedy Sought
To issue an appropriate writ, order or direction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, quashing and setting aside the impugned revisional order dated 25 November 2024 passed in Revision Application No. 409 of 2024 and restoring the original order dated 18 August 2022 granting deemed membership to petitioner No. 1 in respect of Unit No. 601 under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
Filing Reason
The petitioners filed the writ petition challenging the revisional order dated 25 November 2024, whereby the Divisional Joint Registrar set aside the order granting deemed membership of the co-operative housing society under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, despite the petitioners holding a registered agreement for sale under MOFA. The petition was filed on grounds of lack of jurisdiction of the revisional authority and wrongful denial of the petitioners' statutory membership right.
Previous Decisions
1.Order dated 18 August 2022 passed by the Registrar under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, granting deemed membership to petitioner No. 1 in respect of Unit No. 601.
2.Consequential order dated 24 April 2024 passed under Section 79(2)(b) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, appointing an authorised officer to implement the deemed membership order.
3.Revisional order dated 25 November 2024 passed by the Divisional Joint Registrar in Revision Application No. 409 of 2024, setting aside the order dated 18 August 2022 granting deemed membership and the consequential order dated 24 April 2024 appointing the authorised officer.
Issues
1. Whether the revisional order dated 25 November 2024 suffered from lack of jurisdiction in view of the State Government Notification dated 8 October 2024 transferring appellate powers under Sections 152 and 154 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, to the Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies (SRA), Mumbai.
2. Whether the petitioners, having entered into a registered agreement for sale in Form No. 5 under Section 4 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963, could be treated as persons who had 'taken' flats and were entitled to claim society membership despite non-payment of the entire consideration.
3. Whether the pendency of S.C. Suit No. 2225 of 2016 seeking enforcement of the agreement for sale operated as a bar to granting deemed membership under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
Submissions/Arguments
The petitioners advanced the following submissions:
1. Validity of registered agreement: The registered agreement for sale dated 16 September 2013, executed between the petitioners and respondent Nos. 1 and 2, was undisputed. The developers themselves had instituted a civil suit seeking enforcement of the same agreement.
2. Compliance with MOFA: The agreement satisfied the requirements of Section 4 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963, and was executed in Form No. 5 prescribed under the Act.
3. Right to society membership: The petitioners contended that they were purchasers who had 'taken' flats within the meaning of MOFA and were consequently entitled to exercise the statutory rights available to flat purchasers, including membership of the co-operative housing society.
4. Unpaid consideration: The developers could, at best, be treated as unpaid sellers, whose remedies were governed by Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Non-payment of the balance consideration could not defeat the petitioners' statutory membership rights.
5. Lack of jurisdiction: The State Government Notification dated 8 October 2024, issued under Section 3 of the MCS Act, conferred the Registrar's powers under Sections 152 and 154 upon the Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies (SRA), Mumbai, in respect of societies falling within the SRA jurisdiction.
6. Invalidity of revisional order: Since the notification had already transferred the revisional jurisdiction, respondent No. 3 lacked authority to entertain and decide Revision Application No. 409 of 2024 on 25 November 2024. Therefore, the impugned revisional order deserved to be quashed and set aside.
3. Submissions and Arguments of the Respondents (Developers)
The respondents opposed the writ petition on the following grounds:
1. Outstanding consideration: The respondents relied upon Clauses 3.3, 3.4, 3.9 and 48 of the agreement for sale dated 16 September 2013, which imposed an obligation upon the petitioners to pay the balance sale consideration.
2. Purchaser's status: They contended that unless the entire consideration was paid to the developers, the petitioners could not be treated as purchasers who had 'taken' flats within the meaning of MOFA and, therefore, were not entitled to claim society membership.
3. Agreement as title document: They relied upon Clause 48 of the agreement, which provided that the agreement itself would constitute the document of title in favour of the petitioners and that no further conveyance was required. However, they argued that the obligation to pay the entire consideration continued.
4. Jurisdiction of the Revisional Authority: The respondents submitted that although the State Government had issued the Notification dated 8 October 2024 transferring appellate powers to the Joint Registrar (SRA), Mumbai, the newly designated office did not become operational until February–March 2025. Therefore, respondent No. 3 continued to exercise jurisdiction when it passed the revisional order on 25 November 2024.
5. Reliance on Supreme Court judgment: They relied upon Lal Shah Baba Dargah Trust v. Magnum Developers and Others, (2015) 17 SCC 65, to contend that the existing authority could continue exercising jurisdiction until the newly designated authority became operational.
6. Restoration of an allegedly illegal order: The respondents further argued that even if the revisional order was found to be without jurisdiction, setting it aside would revive the original order granting deemed membership, which they claimed was itself illegal. They relied upon Maharaja Chintamani Saran Nath Shahdeo v. State of Bihar and Others, (1999) 8 SCC 16, and submitted that the High Court should not exercise its discretionary writ jurisdiction to restore an illegal order.
Ratio Decidendi
The Bombay High Court held that a purchaser who has entered into a valid registered agreement for sale in Form No. 5 under Section 4 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963, is entitled to claim membership of a co-operative housing society as a person who has 'taken' a flat. Non-payment of the entire sale consideration does not, by itself, defeat such statutory membership rights, and the developer's remedy for recovery of outstanding consideration lies under applicable property law.
The Court further held that the mere pendency of a civil suit seeking enforcement of the agreement for sale does not operate as a bar to granting deemed membership under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, in the absence of an injunction or restraining order passed by the civil court. Such membership determination does not finally adjudicate ownership or title and remains subject to the outcome of the civil proceedings.
Additionally, where the State Government validly transfers revisional jurisdiction to a newly designated authority by notification under Section 3 of the MCS Act, the transfer takes effect from the date of notification, and the earlier authority cannot continue exercising such jurisdiction merely because the newly designated office has not commenced physical functioning.
Judgment Excerpts
1. On transfer of jurisdiction under Section 3 of MCS Act
Paragraphs 14–16
The Court held that the Notification dated 8 October 2024 transferred appellate jurisdiction to the Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies (SRA), Mumbai, with effect from the date of its issuance.
The earlier appellate authority cannot deal with such matters after that date.
The Court clarified that administrative delay in making the newly designated office operational could not preserve the jurisdiction of the earlier authority. Pasted text(20261118-124501).txt
2. On distinction from Lal Shah Baba Dargah Trust
Paragraphs 17–20
The Court distinguished Lal Shah Baba Dargah Trust v. Magnum Developers and Others, (2015) 17 SCC 65.
It observed that the Supreme Court had permitted the existing Tribunal to continue because the newly contemplated Tribunal had not yet been constituted, thereby avoiding a legal vacuum.
In the present case, the new appellate authority had already been legally constituted through the Government Notification. Therefore, the earlier authority could not continue exercising jurisdiction merely because the new office was not physically operational. Pasted text(20261118-124501).txt
3. On registered MOFA agreement and membership rights
Paragraphs 22–26
The Court recognised that a registered agreement for sale executed in Form No. 5 under Section 4 of MOFA confers statutory rights upon flat purchasers.
It explained that Sections 4 and 10 of MOFA, read with Section 154-B-1(18) of the MCS Act, recognise the rights of purchasers in relation to the formation and membership of co-operative housing societies.
The Court observed that a purchaser under a valid registered MOFA agreement could be treated as a person who had 'taken' a flat for the purpose of claiming society membership. Pasted text(20261118-124501).txt
4. On non-payment of balance consideration
Paragraphs 26–29
The developer cannot use unpaid dues as a weapon to block the purchaser from entering the society.
The Court held that non-payment of the remaining sale consideration does not automatically deprive a purchaser of membership rights.
The developer retains the right to recover outstanding consideration under Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. However, such financial claims cannot be used to defeat the purchaser's entitlement to society membership. Pasted text(20261118-124501).txt
5. On pendency of civil suit
Paragraph 30
A pending civil suit does not automatically stop society from acting.
The Court held that the pendency of S.C. Suit No. 2225 of 2016 did not constitute an automatic bar to granting deemed membership.
It clarified that:
- Membership determination is provisional in nature.
- It does not finally determine ownership or title.
- The civil court retains jurisdiction over questions of title.
- In the absence of an injunction or restraining order, the Registrar can proceed with the membership determination, subject to the civil suit's outcome. Pasted text(20261118-124501).txt
6. Final operative directions
Paragraphs 31–33
The writ petition is allowed.
The Bombay High Court:
1. Quashed and set aside the revisional order dated 25 November 2024 passed in Revision Application No. 409 of 2024.
2. Restored the Registrar's order dated 18 August 2022 granting deemed membership to petitioner No. 1 in respect of Unit No. 601.
3. Directed that the pending civil suit proceed in accordance with law, uninfluenced by the observations made in the judgment.
4. Made no order as to costs.
5. Rejected the respondents' request for stay of the judgment.
Procedural History
1. 16 September 2013: The petitioners entered into a registered agreement for sale with respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in respect of Unit No. 601.
2. 5 March 2014: A Rectification Deed was executed to correct the name of the purchaser.
3. 2016: Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (developers) instituted S.C. Suit No. 2225 of 2016 before the City Civil Court at Dindoshi, seeking enforcement of the agreement for sale and an injunction restraining the petitioners from creating third-party rights.
4. 29 November 2021: Petitioner No. 2 applied for membership of respondent No. 6, Hubtown Viva Premises Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. The society failed to communicate any decision or reasons.
5. 18 August 2022: The Registrar granted deemed membership to petitioner No. 1 under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
6. 24 April 2024: An authorised officer was appointed under Section 79(2)(b) of the MCS Act to implement the deemed membership order.
7. 8 October 2024: The State Government issued a notification under Section 3 of the MCS Act transferring appellate powers under Sections 152 and 154 to the Joint Registrar, Co-operative Societies (SRA), Mumbai, for societies within the SRA jurisdiction.
8. 25 November 2024: The Divisional Joint Registrar, Mumbai Division, allowed Revision Application No. 409 of 2024 filed by the developers and set aside the order dated 18 August 2022 granting deemed membership.
9. 2025: Aggrieved by the revisional order, the petitioners filed Writ Petition No. 13583 of 2025 before the Bombay High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
10. 6 January 2026: The Bombay High Court reserved the matter for judgment.
11. 16 January 2026: The Bombay High Court allowed the writ petition, quashed and set aside the revisional order dated 25 November 2024 and restored the Registrar's order dated 18 August 2022 granting deemed membership to petitioner No. 1 in respect of Unit No. 601.
12. Final directions: The Court directed that S.C. Suit No. 2225 of 2016 proceed in accordance with law, uninfluenced by the observations made in the judgment. No order as to costs was passed, and the request for stay was rejected.
Acts & Sections
- Constitution of India: Article 226
- Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960: Section 22(2), Section 79(b), Section 152, Section 154
- Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963: Section 4
- Transfer of Property Act, 1882: Section 55