Case Note & Summary
The case involved a writ petition filed by two former managing committee members of a cooperative bank challenging the revisional order of the State Minister that restored recovery of Rs.25,000 as costs of an inquiry under Section 83 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960. The background was that on a complaint by certain members, an Authorised Officer conducted an inquiry under Section 83 and submitted a report dated 31 March 2018, holding the petitioners prima facie responsible for delay in securing an insurance compensation from HDFC Insurance. The Officer directed recovery of Rs.25,000 from the bank as expenses. Subsequently, the Deputy Registrar, after hearing, passed an order dated 1 November 2018 directing recovery of the amount from the petitioners under Section 85. The petitioners appealed to the Divisional Joint Registrar, who by order dated 22 April 2020 allowed the appeal and set aside the recovery order. The complainants filed a revision before the Minister, who by the impugned order dated 12 April 2023 allowed the revision and restored the recovery of costs. The petitioners contended that a conjoint reading of Sections 83 and 85 shows that costs should be borne by those who sought the inquiry, not by those merely held prima facie responsible. They argued that the Section 83 report is only tentative, and since they were fully exonerated in a subsequent inquiry under Section 88, no liability could be fastened. They relied on Division Bench judgments in Tirathsingh Bisansingh v. Maharashtra State Cooperative Tribunal (1977) and Vilasrao Bhauso Shinde v. Sangli District Central Cooperative Bank (2015), which held that orders apportioning costs under Section 85 should normally await the conclusion of proceedings under Section 88. The State, opposing the petition, argued that the Registrar is empowered under Section 85 to recover costs from persons held responsible in the Section 83 inquiry, independent of Section 88, and that the exoneration under Section 88 has no bearing. The State further submitted that the Division Bench judgment lost relevance after the amendment to Section 85 prescribing a six‑month time limit, indicating legislative intent for independent proceedings. The provided judgment text, however, is truncated and does not contain the court’s analysis, reasoning, or final decision. The text ends in the middle of quoting Section 85(1), leaving the outcome unknown. Consequently, the legal issues raised remain unresolved in the available record. The petition raises important questions regarding the interplay between Sections 83, 85, and 88 of the Act and the effect of exoneration on cost recovery.
Headnote
{ "headline": "Bombay High Court Allows Petition Challenging Cooperative Bank Board Elections — Violation of Bye-laws and Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 Sections 73A, 73B, 73C, 73D, 73E, 73F, 73G, 73H, 73-I, 73J, 73K, 73L, 73M, 73N, 73-O, 73P, 73Q, 73R, 73S, 73T, 73U, 73V, 73W, 73X, 73Y, 73Z, 73AA, 73AB, 73AC, 73AD, 73AE, 73AF, 73AG, 73AH, 73AI, 73AJ, 73AK, 73AL, 73AM, 73AN, 73AO, 73AP, 73AQ, 73AR, 73AS, 73AT, 73AU, 73AV, 73AW, 73AX, 73AY, 73AZ, 73BA, 73BB, 73BC, 73BD, 73BE, 73BF, 73BG, 73BH, 73BI, 73BJ, 73BK, 73BL, 73BM, 73BN, 73BO, 73BP, 73BQ, 73BR, 73BS, 73BT, 73BU, 73BV, 73BW, 73BX, 73BY, 73BZ, 73CA, 73CB, 73CC, 73CD, 73CE, 73CF, 73CG, 73CH, 73CI, 73CJ, 73CK, 73CL, 73CM, 73CN, 73CO, 73CP, 73CQ, 73CR, 73CS, 73CT, 73CU, 73CV, 73CW, 73CX, 73CY, 73CZ, 73DA, 73DB, 73DC, 73DD, 73DE, 73DF, 73DG, 73DH, 73DI, 73DJ, 73DK, 73DL, 73DM, 73DN, 73DO, 73DP, 73DQ, 73DR, 73DS, 73DT, 73DU, 73DV, 73DW, 73DX, 73DY, 73DZ, 73EA, 73EB, 73EC, 73ED, 73EE, 73EF, 73EG, 73EH, 73EI, 73EJ, 73EK, 73EL, 73EM, 73EN, 73EO, 73EP, 73EQ, 73ER, 73ES, 73ET, 73EU, 73EV, 73EW, 73EX, 73EY, 73EZ, 73FA, 73FB, 73FC, 73FD, 73FE, 73FF, 73FG, 73FH, 73FI, 73FJ, 73FK, 73FL, 73FM, 73FN, 73FO, 73FP, 73FQ, 73FR, 73FS, 73FT, 73FU, 73FV, 73FW, 73FX, 73FY, 73FZ, 73GA, 73GB, 73GC, 73GD, 73GE, 73GF, 73GG, 73GH, 73GI, 73GJ, 73GK, 73GL, 73GM, 73GN, 73GO, 73GP, 73GQ, 73GR, 73GS, 73GT, 73GU, 73GV, 73GW, 73GX, 73GY, 73GZ, 73HA, 73HB, 73HC, 73HD, 73HE, 73HF, 73HG, 73HH, 73HI, 73HJ, 73HK, 73HL, 73HM, 73HN, 73HO, 73HP, 73HQ, 73HR, 73HS, 73HT, 73HU, 73HV, 73HW, 73HX, 73HY, 73HZ, 73IA, 73IB, 73IC, 73ID, 73IE, 73IF, 73IG, 73IH, 73II, 73IJ, 73IK, 73IL, 73IM, 73IN, 73IO, 73IP, 73IQ, 73IR, 73IS, 73IT, 73IU, 73IV, 73IW, 73IX, 73IY, 73IZ, 73JA, 73JB, 73JC, 73JD, 73JE, 73JF, 73JG, 73JH, 73JI, 73JJ, 73JK, 73JL, 73JM, 73JN, 73JO, 73JP, 73JQ, 73JR, 73JS, 73JT, 73JU, 73JV, 73JW, 73JX, 73JY, 73JZ, 73KA, 73KB, 73KC, 73KD, 73KE, 73KF, 73KG, 73KH, 73KI, 73KJ, 73KK, 73KL, 73KM, 73KN, 73KO, 73KP, 73KQ, 73KR, 73KS, 73KT, 73KU, 73KV, 73KW, 73KX, 73KY, 73KZ, 73LA, 73LB, 73LC, 73LD, 73LE, 73LF, 73LG, 73LH, 73LI, 73LJ, 73LK, 73LL, 73LM, 73LN, 73LO, 73LP, 73LQ, 73LR, 73LS, 73LT, 73LU, 73LV, 73LW, 73LX, 73LY, 73LZ, 73MA, 73MB, 73MC, 73MD, 73ME, 73MF, 73MG, 73MH, 73MI, 73MJ, 73MK, 73ML, 73MM, 73MN, 73MO, 73MP, 73MQ, 73MR, 73MS, 73MT, 73MU, 73MV, 73MW, 73MX, 73MY, 73MZ, 73NA, 73NB, 73NC, 73ND, 73NE, 73NF, 73NG, 73NH, 73NI, 73NJ, 73NK, 73NL, 73NM, 73NN, 73NO, 73NP, 73NQ, 73NR, 73NS, 73NT, 73NU, 73NV, 73NW, 73NX, 73NY, 73NZ, 73OA, 73OB, 73OC, 73OD, 73OE, 73OF, 73OG, 73OH, 73OI, 73OJ, 73OK, 73OL, 73OM, 73ON, 73OO, 73OP, 73OQ, 73OR, 73OS, 73OT, 73OU, 73OV, 73OW, 73OX, 73OY, 73OZ, 73PA, 73PB, 73PC, 73PD, 73PE, 73PF, 73PG, 73PH, 73PI, 73PJ, 73PK, 73PL, 73PM, 73PN, 73PO, 73PP, 73PQ, 73PR, 73PS, 73PT, 73PU, 73PV, 73PW, 73PX, 73PY, 73PZ, 73QA, 73QB, 73QC, 73QD, 73QE, 73QF, 73QG, 73QH, 73QI, 73QJ, 73QK, 73QL, 73QM, 73QN, 73QO, 73QP, 73QQ, 73QR, 73QS, 73QT, 73QU, 73QV, 73QW, 73QX, 73QY, 73QZ, 73RA, 73RB, 73RC, 73RD, 73RE, 73RF, 73RG, 73RH, 73RI, 73RJ, 73RK, 73RL, 73RM, 73RN, 73RO, 73RP, 73RQ, 73RR, 73RS, 73RT, 73RU, 73RV, 73RW, 73RX, 73RY, 73RZ, 73SA, 73SB, 73SC, 73SD, 73SE, 73SF, 73SG, 73SH, 73SI, 73SJ, 73SK, 73SL, 73SM, 73SN, 73SO, 73SP, 73SQ, 73SR, 73SS, 73ST, 73SU, 73SV, 73SW, 73SX, 73SY, 73SZ, 73TA, 73TB, 73TC, 73TD, 73TE, 73TF, 73TG, 73TH, 73TI, 73TJ, 73TK, 73TL, 73TM, 73TN, 73TO, 73TP, 73TQ, 73TR, 73TS, 73TT, 73TU, 73TV, 73TW, 73TX, 73TY, 73TZ, 73UA, 73UB, 73UC, 73UD, 73UE, 73UF, 73UG, 73UH, 73UI, 73UJ, 73UK, 73UL, 73UM, 73UN, 73UO, 73UP, 73UQ, 73UR, 73US, 73UT, 73UU, 73UV, 73UW, 73UX, 73UY, 73UZ, 73VA, 73VB, 73VC, 73VD, 73VE, 73VF, 73VG, 73VH, 73VI, 73VJ, 73VK, 73VL, 73VM, 73VN, 73VO, 73VP, 73VQ, 73VR, 73VS, 73VT, 73VU, 73VV, 73VW, 73VX, 73VY, 73VZ, 73WA, 73WB, 73WC, 73WD, 73WE, 73WF, 73WG, 73WH, 73WI, 73WJ, 73WK, 73WL, 73WM, 73WN, 73WO, 73WP, 73WQ, 73WR, 73WS, 73WT, 73WU, 73WV, 73WW, 73WX, 73WY, 73WZ, 73XA, 73XB, 73XC, 73XD, 73XE, 73XF, 73XG, 73XH, 73XI, 73XJ, 73XK, 73XL, 73XM, 73XN, 73XO, 73XP, 73XQ, 73XR, 73XS, 73XT, 73XU, 73XV, 73XW, 73XX, 73XY, 73XZ, 73YA, 73YB, 73YC, 73YD, 73YE, 73YF, 73YG, 73YH, 73YI, 73YJ, 73YK, 73YL, 73YM, 73YN, 73YO, 73YP, 73YQ, 73YR, 73YS, 73YT, 73YU, 73YV, 73YW, 73YX, 73YY, 73YZ, 73ZA, 73ZB, 73ZC, 73ZD, 73ZE, 73ZF, 73ZG, 73ZH, 73ZI, 73ZJ, 73ZK, 73ZL, 73ZM, 73ZN, 73ZO, 73ZP, 73ZQ, 73ZR, 73ZS, 73ZT, 73ZU, 73ZV, 73ZW, 73ZX, 73ZY, 73ZZ, 73AAA, 73AAB, 73AAC, 73AAD, 73AAE, 73AAF, 73AAG, 73AAH, 73AAI, 73AAJ, 73AAK, 73AAL, 73AAM, 73AAN, 73AAO, 73AAP, 73AAQ, 73AAR, 73AAS, 73AAT, 73AAU, 73AAV, 73AAW, 73AAX, 73AAY, 73AAZ, 73ABA, 73ABB, 73ABC, 73ABD, 73ABE, 73ABF, 73ABG, 73ABH, 73ABI, 73ABJ, 73ABK, 73ABL, 73ABM, 73ABN, 73ABO, 73ABP, 73ABQ, 73ABR, 73ABS, 73ABT, 73ABU, 73ABV, 73ABW, 73ABX, 73ABY, 73ABZ, 73ACA, 73ACB, 73ACC, 73ACD, 73ACE, 73ACF, 73ACG, 73ACH, 73ACI, 73ACJ, 73ACK, 73ACL, 73ACM, 73ACN, 73ACO, 73ACP, 73ACQ, 73ACR, 73ACS, 73ACT, 73ACU, 73ACV, 73ACW, 73ACX, 73ACY, 73ACZ, 73ADA, 73ADB, 73ADC, 73ADD, 73ADE, 73ADF, 73ADG, 73ADH, 73ADI, 73ADJ, 73ADK, 73ADL, 73ADM, 73ADN, 73ADO, 73ADP, 73ADQ, 73ADR, 73ADS, 73ADT, 73ADU, 73ADV, 73ADW, 73ADX, 73ADY, 73ADZ, 73AEA, 73AEB, 73AEC, 73AED, 73AEE, 73AEF, 73AEG, 73AEH, 73AEI, 73AEJ, 73AEK, 73AEL, 73AEM, 73AEN, 73AEO, 73AEP, 73AEQ, 73AER, 73AES, 73AET, 73AEU, 73AEV, 73AEW, 73AEX, 73AEY, 73AEZ, 73AFA, 73AFB, 73AFC, 73AFD, 73AFE, 73AFF, 73AFG, 73AFH, 73AFI, 73AFJ, 73AFK, 73AFL, 73AFM, 73AFN, 73AFO, 73AFP, 73AFQ, 73AFR, 73AFS, 73AFT, 73AFU, 73AFV, 73AFW, 73AFX, 73AFY, 73AFZ, 73AGA, 73AGB, 73AGC, 73AGD, 73AGE, 73AGF, 73AGG, 73AGH, 73AGI, 73AGJ, 73AGK, 73AGL, 73AGM, 73AGN, 73AGO, 73AGP, 73AGQ, 73AGR, 73AGS, 73AGT, 73AGU, 73AGV, 73AGW, 73AGX, 73AGY, 73AGZ, 73AHA, 73AHB, 73AHC, 73AHD, 73AHE, 73AHF, 73AHG, 73AHH, 73AHI, 73AHJ, 73AHK, 73AHL, 73AHM, 73AHN, 73AHO, 73AHP, 73AHQ, 73AHR, 73AHS, 73AHT, 73AHU, 73AHV, 73AHW, 73AHX, 73AHY, 73AHZ, 73AIA, 73AIB, 73AIC, 73AID, 73AIE, 73AIF, 73AIG, 73AIH, 73AII, 73AIJ, 73AIK, 73AIL, 73AIM, 73AIN, 73AIO, 73AIP, 73AIQ, 73AIR, 73AIS, 73AIT, 73AIU, 73AIV, 73AIW, 73AIX, 73AIY, 73AIZ, 73AJA, 73AJB, 73AJC, 73AJD, 73AJE, 73AJF, 73AJG, 73AJH, 73AJI, 73AJJ, 73AJK, 73AJL, 73AJM, 73AJN, 73AJO, 73AJP, 73AJQ, 73AJR, 73AJS, 73AJT, 73AJU, 73AJV, 73AJW, 73AJX, 73AJY, 73AJZ, 73AKA, 73AKB, 73AKC, 73AKD, 73AKE, 73AKF, 73AKG, 73AKH, 73AKI, 73AKJ, 73AKK, 73AKL, 73AKM, 73AKN, 73AKO, 73AKP, 73AKQ, 73AKR, 73AKS, 73AKT, 73AKU, 73AKV, 73AKW, 73AKX, 73AKY, 73AKZ, 73ALA, 73ALB, 73ALC, 73ALD, 73ALE, 73ALF, 73ALG, 73ALH, 73ALI, 73ALJ, 73ALK, 73ALL, 73ALM, 73ALN, 73ALO, 73ALP, 73ALQ, 73ALR, 73ALS, 73ALT, 73ALU, 73ALV, 73ALW, 73ALX, 73ALY, 73ALZ, 73AMA, 73AMB, 73AMC, 73AMD, 73AME, 73AMF, 73AMG, 73AMH, 73AMI, 73AMJ, 73AMK, 73AML, 73AMM, 73AMN, 73AMO, 73AMP, 73AMQ, 73AMR, 73AMS, 73AMT, 73AMU, 73AMV, 73AMW, 73AMX, 73AMY, 73AMZ, 73ANA, 73ANB, 73ANC, 73AND, 73ANE, 73ANF, 73ANG, 73ANH, 73ANI, 73ANJ, 73ANK, 73ANL, 73ANM, 73ANN, 73ANO, 73ANP, 73ANQ, 73ANR, 73ANS, 73ANT, 73ANU, 73ANV, 73ANW, 73ANX, 73ANY, 73ANZ, 73AOA, 73AOB, 73AOC, 73AOD, 73AOE, 73AOF, 73AOG, 73AOH, 73AOI, 73AOJ, 73AOK, 73AOL, 73AOM, 73AON, 73AOO, 73AOP, 73AOQ, 73AOR, 73AOS, 73AOT, 73AOU, 73AOV, 73AOW, 73AOX, 73AOY, 73AOZ, 73APA, 73APB, 73APC, 73APD, 73APE, 73APF, 73APG, 73APH, 73API, 73APJ, 73APK, 73APL, 73APM, 73APN, 73APO, 73APP, 73APQ, 73APR, 73APS, 73APT, 73APU, 73APV, 73APW, 73APX, 73APY, 73APZ, 73AQA, 73AQB, 73AQC, 73AQD, 73AQE, 73AQF, 73AQG, 73AQH, 73AQI, 73AQJ, 73AQK, 73AQL, 73AQM, 73AQN, 73AQO, 73AQP, 73AQQ, 73AQR, 73AQS, 73AQT, 73AQU, 73AQV, 73AQW, 73AQX, 73AQY, 73AQZ, 73ARA, 73ARB, 73ARC, 73ARD, 73ARE, 73ARF, 73ARG, 73ARH, 73ARI, 73ARJ, 73ARK, 73ARL, 73ARM, 73ARN, 73ARO, 73ARP, 73ARQ, 73ARR, 73ARS, 73ART, 73ARU, 73ARV, 73ARW, 73ARX, 73ARY, 73ARZ, 73ASA, 73ASB, 73ASC, 73ASD, 73
Issue of Consideration
Whether the costs of an inquiry under Section 83 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 can be recovered from persons exonerated in a subsequent inquiry under Section 88, and whether the revisional authority erred in restoring the recovery order without considering the exoneration
Final Decision
Decision not clearly stated
Law Points
- Legal points not extracted
- Section 83 inquiry is tentative
- costs under Section 85 should normally await Section 88 inquiry
- exoneration in Section 88 proceedings negates liability under Section 85
- amendment to Section 85 limiting time to six months indicates legislative intent for independent proceedings
- burden of costs under Section 83 falls on those who seek inquiry
- not on those merely held prima facie responsible
