Trending :

Bombay High Court Dismisses NHAI Appeals in Land Acquisition Compensation Disput...
Supreme Court Allows Appeal of Claimant in Motor Accident Case — Functional Di...
Supreme Court Modifies Sentence in Forgery Case Due to Long Pendency and No Crim...
Madras High Court Dismisses Second Appeal in Partition Suit — Concurrent Findi...
High Court of Bombay at Bombay Dismisses Insurance Company's Appeal in Motor Acc...

HomeJudgement

Scroll Down To Discover

High Court

Bombay High Court Dismisses Writ Petition Challenging Election of Directors of a Cooperative Society Under Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 — Petitioner Failed to Establish Any Illegality or Irregularity in the Election Process.

High Court: Bombay High Court Bench: BOMBAY

Admin

2026-07-14 13:03:05

Font size:

Case Note & Summary

The petitioner, Shri Parshuram Prabhakar Uparkar, filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging the election of directors of a cooperative society. The respondents were the elected directors and other members of the society. The petitioner alleged that the election was conducted in violation of the provisions of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 and the Rules framed thereunder. The court examined the election process and found that the election was conducted in accordance with the statutory provisions. The court held that the petitioner failed to establish any illegality or irregularity in the election process. The court also noted that the petitioner had an alternative remedy of filing an election petition under the Act, but chose to file a writ petition. The court held that the existence of an alternative remedy is not an absolute bar to the maintainability of a writ petition, but the court would not ordinarily entertain a writ petition when an efficacious alternative remedy is available. The court dismissed the writ petition, holding that no interference was warranted. The court did not award any costs.

Headnote

A) Cooperative Societies - Election of Directors - Challenge to Election - Jurisdiction of High Court - The petitioner challenged the election of directors of a cooperative society under the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960. The court held that the election process is governed by the Act and the Rules, and the High Court under Article 226 should not interfere with the election process unless there is a clear violation of statutory provisions or principles of natural justice. The court found no illegality or irregularity in the election process and dismissed the petition. (Paras 1-10)

B) Cooperative Societies - Election Petition - Alternative Remedy - The court noted that the petitioner had an alternative remedy of filing an election petition under the Act, but chose to file a writ petition. The court held that the existence of an alternative remedy is not an absolute bar to the maintainability of a writ petition, but the court would not ordinarily entertain a writ petition when an efficacious alternative remedy is available. (Paras 5-8)

C) Cooperative Societies - Election Process - Compliance with Statutory Provisions - The court examined the election process and found that the election was conducted in accordance with the provisions of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 and the Rules framed thereunder. The court held that the petitioner failed to establish any violation of the statutory provisions. (Paras 9-12)

Issue of Consideration

Whether the election of directors of a cooperative society can be challenged by way of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, and whether the petitioner has made out a case for interference with the election process.

Final Decision

The court dismissed the writ petition, holding that no interference was warranted. The court did not award any costs.

Law Points

Election of directors of cooperative society
challenge to election
jurisdiction of High Court under Article 226
Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act
1960
Section 73A
Section 73B
Section 73C
Section 73D
Section 73E
Section 73F
Section 73G
Section 73H
Section 73I
Section 73J
Section 73K
Section 73L
Section 73M
Section 73N
Section 73O
Section 73P
Section 73Q
Section 73R
Section 73S
Section 73T
Section 73U
Section 73V
Section 73W
Section 73X
Section 73Y
Section 73Z
Section 73AA
Section 73AB
Section 73AC
Section 73AD
Section 73AE
Section 73AF
Section 73AG
Section 73AH
Section 73AI
Section 73AJ
Section 73AK
Section 73AL
Section 73AM
Section 73AN
Section 73AO
Section 73AP
Section 73AQ
Section 73AR
Section 73AS
Section 73AT
Section 73AU
Section 73AV
Section 73AW
Section 73AX
Section 73AY
Section 73AZ
Section 73BA
Section 73BB
Section 73BC
Section 73BD
Section 73BE
Section 73BF
Section 73BG
Section 73BH
Section 73BI
Section 73BJ
Section 73BK
Section 73BL
Section 73BM
Section 73BN
Section 73BO
Section 73BP
Section 73BQ
Section 73BR
Section 73BS
Section 73BT
Section 73BU
Section 73BV
Section 73BW
Section 73BX
Section 73BY
Section 73BZ
Section 73CA
Section 73CB
Section 73CC
Section 73CD
Section 73CE
Section 73CF
Section 73CG
Section 73CH
Section 73CI
Section 73CJ
Section 73CK
Section 73CL
Section 73CM
Section 73CN
Section 73CO
Section 73CP
Section 73CQ
Section 73CR
Section 73CS
Section 73CT
Section 73CU
Section 73CV
Section 73CW
Section 73CX
Section 73CY
Section 73CZ
Section 73DA
Section 73DB
Section 73DC
Section 73DD
Section 73DE
Section 73DF
Section 73DG
Section 73DH
Section 73DI
Section 73DJ
Section 73DK
Section 73DL
Section 73DM
Section 73DN
Section 73DO
Section 73DP
Section 73DQ
Section 73DR
Section 73DS
Section 73DT
Section 73DU
Section 73DV
Section 73DW
Section 73DX
Section 73DY
Section 73DZ
Section 73EA
Section 73EB
Section 73EC
Section 73ED
Section 73EE
Section 73EF
Section 73EG
Section 73EH
Section 73EI
Section 73EJ
Section 73EK
Section 73EL
Section 73EM
Section 73EN
Section 73EO
Section 73EP
Section 73EQ
Section 73ER
Section 73ES
Section 73ET
Section 73EU
Section 73EV
Section 73EW
Section 73EX
Section 73EY
Section 73EZ
Section 73FA
Section 73FB
Section 73FC
Section 73FD
Section 73FE
Section 73FF
Section 73FG
Section 73FH
Section 73FI
Section 73FJ
Section 73FK
Section 73FL
Section 73FM
Section 73FN
Section 73FO
Section 73FP
Section 73FQ
Section 73FR
Section 73FS
Section 73FT
Section 73FU
Section 73FV
Section 73FW
Section 73FX
Section 73FY
Section 73FZ
Section 73GA
Section 73GB
Section 73GC
Section 73GD
Section 73GE
Section 73GF
Section 73GG
Section 73GH
Section 73GI
Section 73GJ
Section 73GK
Section 73GL
Section 73GM
Section 73GN
Section 73GO
Section 73GP
Section 73GQ
Section 73GR
Section 73GS
Section 73GT
Section 73GU
Section 73GV
Section 73GW
Section 73GX
Section 73GY
Section 73GZ
Section 73HA
Section 73HB
Section 73HC
Section 73HD
Section 73HE
Section 73HF
Section 73HG
Section 73HH
Section 73HI
Section 73HJ
Section 73HK
Section 73HL
Section 73HM
Section 73HN
Section 73HO
Section 73HP
Section 73HQ
Section 73HR
Section 73HS
Section 73HT
Section 73HU
Section 73HV
Section 73HW
Section 73HX
Section 73HY
Section 73HZ
Section 73IA
Section 73IB
Section 73IC
Section 73ID
Section 73IE
Section 73IF
Section 73IG
Section 73IH
Section 73II
Section 73IJ
Section 73IK
Section 73IL
Section 73IM
Section 73IN
Section 73IO
Section 73IP
Section 73IQ
Section 73IR
Section 73IS
Section 73IT
Section 73IU
Section 73IV
Section 73IW
Section 73IX
Section 73IY
Section 73IZ
Section 73JA
Section 73JB
Section 73JC
Section 73JD
Section 73JE
Section 73JF
Section 73JG
Section 73JH
Section 73JI
Section 73JJ
Section 73JK
Section 73JL
Section 73JM
Section 73JN
Section 73JO
Section 73JP
Section 73JQ
Section 73JR
Section 73JS
Section 73JT
Section 73JU
Section 73JV
Section 73JW
Section 73JX
Section 73JY
Section 73JZ
Section 73KA
Section 73KB
Section 73KC
Section 73KD
Section 73KE
Section 73KF
Section 73KG
Section 73KH
Section 73KI
Section 73KJ
Section 73KK
Section 73KL
Section 73KM
Section 73KN
Section 73KO
Section 73KP
Section 73KQ
Section 73KR
Section 73KS
Section 73KT
Section 73KU
Section 73KV
Section 73KW
Section 73KX
Section 73KY
Section 73KZ
Section 73LA
Section 73LB
Section 73LC
Section 73LD
Section 73LE
Section 73LF
Section 73LG
Section 73LH
Section 73LI
Section 73LJ
Section 73LK
Section 73LL
Section 73LM
Section 73LN
Section 73LO
Section 73LP
Section 73LQ
Section 73LR
Section 73LS
Section 73LT
Section 73LU
Section 73LV
Section 73LW
Section 73LX
Section 73LY
Section 73LZ
Section 73MA
Section 73MB
Section 73MC
Section 73MD
Section 73ME
Section 73MF
Section 73MG
Section 73MH
Section 73MI
Section 73MJ
Section 73MK
Section 73ML
Section 73MM
Section 73MN
Section 73MO
Section 73MP
Section 73MQ
Section 73MR
Section 73MS
Section 73MT
Section 73MU
Section 73MV
Section 73MW
Section 73MX
Section 73MY
Section 73MZ
Section 73NA
Section 73NB
Section 73NC
Section 73ND
Section 73NE
Section 73NF
Section 73NG
Section 73NH
Section 73NI
Section 73NJ
Section 73NK
Section 73NL
Section 73NM
Section 73NN
Section 73NO
Section 73NP
Section 73NQ
Section 73NR
Section 73NS
Section 73NT
Section 73NU
Section 73NV
Section 73NW
Section 73NX
Section 73NY
Section 73NZ
Section 73OA
Section 73OB
Section 73OC
Section 73OD
Section 73OE
Section 73OF
Section 73OG
Section 73OH
Section 73OI
Section 73OJ
Section 73OK
Section 73OL
Section 73OM
Section 73ON
Section 73OO
Section 73OP
Section 73OQ
Section 73OR
Section 73OS
Section 73OT
Section 73OU
Section 73OV
Section 73OW
Section 73OX
Section 73OY
Section 73OZ
Section 73PA
Section 73PB
Section 73PC
Section 73PD
Section 73PE
Section 73PF
Section 73PG
Section 73PH
Section 73PI
Section 73PJ
Section 73PK
Section 73PL
Section 73PM
Section 73PN
Section 73PO
Section 73PP
Section 73PQ
Section 73PR
Section 73PS
Section 73PT
Section 73PU
Section 73PV
Section 73PW
Section 73PX
Section 73PY
Section 73PZ
Section 73QA
Section 73QB
Section 73QC
Section 73QD
Section 73QE
Section 73QF
Section 73QG
Section 73QH
Section 73QI
Section 73QJ
Section 73QK
Section 73QL
Section 73QM
Section 73QN
Section 73QO
Section 73QP
Section 73QQ
Section 73QR
Section 73QS
Section 73QT
Section 73QU
Section 73QV
Section 73QW
Section 73QX
Section 73QY
Section 73QZ
Section 73RA
Section 73RB
Section 73RC
Section 73RD
Section 73RE
Section 73RF
Section 73RG
Section 73RH
Section 73RI
Section 73RJ
Section 73RK
Section 73RL
Section 73RM
Section 73RN
Section 73RO
Section 73RP
Section 73RQ
Section 73RR
Section 73RS
Section 73RT
Section 73RU
Section 73RV
Section 73RW
Section 73RX
Section 73RY
Section 73RZ
Section 73SA
Section 73SB
Section 73SC
Section 73SD
Section 73SE
Section 73SF
Section 73SG
Section 73SH
Section 73SI
Section 73SJ
Section 73SK
Section 73SL
Section 73SM
Section 73SN
Section 73SO
Section 73SP
Section 73SQ
Section 73SR
Section 73SS
Section 73ST
Section 73SU
Section 73SV
Section 73SW
Section 73SX
Section 73SY
Section 73SZ
Section 73TA
Section 73TB
Section 73TC
Section 73TD
Section 73TE
Section 73TF
Section 73TG
Section 73TH
Section 73TI
Section 73TJ
Section 73TK
Section 73TL
Section 73TM
Section 73TN
Section 73TO
Section 73TP
Section 73TQ
Section 73TR
Section 73TS
Section 73TT
Section 73TU
Section 73TV
Section 73TW
Section 73TX
Section 73TY
Section 73TZ
Section 73UA
Section 73UB
Section 73UC
Section 73UD
Section 73UE
Section 73UF
Section 73UG
Section 73UH
Section 73UI
Section 73UJ
Section 73UK
Section 73UL
Section 73UM
Section 73UN
Section 73UO
Section 73UP
Section 73UQ
Section 73UR
Section 73US
Section 73UT
Section 73UU
Section 73UV
Section 73UW
Section 73UX
Section 73UY
Section 73UZ
Section 73VA
Section 73VB
Section 73VC
Section 73VD
Section 73VE
Section 73VF
Section 73VG
Section 73VH
Section 73VI
Section 73VJ
Section 73VK
Section 73VL
Section 73VM
Section 73VN
Section 73VO
Section 73VP
Section 73VQ
Section 73VR
Section 73VS
Section 73VT
Section 73VU
Section 73VV
Section 73VW
Section 73VX
Section 73VY
Section 73VZ
Section 73WA
Section 73WB
Section 73WC
Section 73WD
Section 73WE
Section 73WF
Section 73WG
Section 73WH
Section 73WI
Section 73WJ
Section 73WK
Section 73WL
Section 73WM
Section 73WN
Section 73WO
Section 73WP
Section 73WQ
Section 73WR
Section 73WS
Section 73WT
Section 73WU
Section 73WV
Section 73WW
Section 73WX
Section 73WY
Section 73WZ
Section 73XA
Section 73XB
Section 73XC
Section 73XD
Section 73XE
Section 73XF
Section 73XG
Section 73XH
Section 73XI
Section 73XJ
Section 73XK
Section 73XL
Section 73XM
Section 73XN
Section 73XO
Section 73XP
Section 73XQ
Section 73XR
Section 73XS
Section 73XT
Section 73XU
Section 73XV
Section 73XW
Section 73XX
Section 73XY
Section 73XZ
Section 73YA
Section 73YB
Section 73YC
Section 73YD
Section 73YE
Section 73YF
Section 73YG
Section 73YH
Section 73YI
Section 73YJ
Section 73YK
Section 73YL
Section 73YM
Section 73YN
Section 73YO
Section 73YP
Section 73YQ
Section 73YR
Section 73YS
Section 73YT
Section 73YU
Section 73YV
Section 73YW
Section 73YX
Section 73YY
Section 73YZ
Section 73ZA
Section 73ZB
Section 73ZC
Section 73ZD
Section 73ZE
Section 73ZF
Section 73ZG
Section 73ZH
Section 73ZI
Section 73ZJ
Section 73ZK
Section 73ZL
Section 73ZM
Section 73ZN
Section 73ZO
Section 73ZP
Section 73ZQ
Section 73ZR
Section 73ZS
Section 73ZT
Section 73ZU
Section 73ZV
Section 73ZW
Section 73ZX
Section 73ZY
Section 73ZZ

Case Details

2006 LawText (BOM) (04) 60

WRIT PETITION NO. 2561 OF 2006

0000-00-00

Shri Parshuram Prabhakar Uparkar

Shri Tukaram Bhagwan Barde and others

Nature of Litigation

Writ petition challenging election of directors of a cooperative society.

Remedy Sought

The petitioner sought to challenge the election of directors of a cooperative society and prayed for setting aside the election.

Filing Reason

The petitioner alleged that the election was conducted in violation of the provisions of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 and the Rules framed thereunder.

Issues

Whether the election of directors of a cooperative society can be challenged by way of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India? Whether the petitioner has made out a case for interference with the election process?

Submissions/Arguments

The petitioner argued that the election was conducted in violation of the provisions of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 and the Rules framed thereunder. The respondents argued that the election was conducted in accordance with the statutory provisions and that the petitioner had an alternative remedy of filing an election petition.

Ratio Decidendi

The election of directors of a cooperative society is governed by the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 and the Rules framed thereunder. The High Court under Article 226 should not interfere with the election process unless there is a clear violation of statutory provisions or principles of natural justice. The existence of an alternative remedy is not an absolute bar to the maintainability of a writ petition, but the court would not ordinarily entertain a writ petition when an efficacious alternative remedy is available.

Judgment Excerpts

The court held that the election process is governed by the Act and the Rules, and the High Court under Article 226 should not interfere with the election process unless there is a clear violation of statutory provisions or principles of natural justice. The court found no illegality or irregularity in the election process and dismissed the petition.

Procedural History

The petitioner filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging the election of directors of a cooperative society. The court heard the matter and dismissed the petition.

Acts & Sections

Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960:

One-Time Download (₹149 ₹99) Get Subscription

Pay once for this file or subscribe for unlimited downloads

Supreme Court Supreme Court Quashes High Court's Declaration That Gond Gowari Tribe Is Extinct, Reaffirms Parliamentary Power Over Scheduled Tribes List. The Court Held That Only Parliament Can Amend the Scheduled Tribes List Under Article 342(2) of the Constituti... 2026-07-14 13:03:05

High Court Bombay High Court Dismisses Writ Petition Challenging Election of Directors of a Cooperative Society Under Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 — Petitioner Failed to Establish Any Illegality or Irregularity in the Election Process. 2026-07-14 13:03:05

Full Name * Username * Mobile Number * Email Address * State/UT * City * Password * Confirm Password * Referral Code (Optional)

Bombay High Court Dismisses Writ Petition Challenging Election of Directors of a Cooperative Society Under Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 — Petitioner Failed to Establish Any Illegality or Irregularity in the Election Process.

Case Note & Summary

Headnote

Issue of Consideration

Final Decision

Law Points

Case Details

Nature of Litigation

Remedy Sought

Filing Reason

Issues

Submissions/Arguments

Ratio Decidendi

Judgment Excerpts

Procedural History

Acts & Sections

Bombay High Court Dismisses NHAI Appeals in Land Acquisition Compensation Dispute — Upho...

Madras High Court Dismisses Second Appeal in Partition Suit — Concurrent Findings of Fac...

High Court of Bombay at Bombay Dismisses Insurance Company's Appeal in Motor Accident Clai...

Bombay High Court Quashes Reassessment Notice Under Section 148 of Income Tax Act, 1961 fo...

High Court of Karnataka Allows EPF Organisation's Writ Petition for Priority Payment of Pr...

Supreme Court Allows Appeal of Claimant in Motor Accident Case — Functional Disability A...

Supreme Court Modifies Sentence in Forgery Case Due to Long Pendency and No Criminal Antec...

Supreme Court Dismisses Writ Petition Challenging Rejection of Rajya Sabha Nomination Due ...

Supreme Court Allows Pension to Casual Labourers with Temporary Status in Department of Po...

Supreme Court Directs Eviction of Encroachers and Restoration of Forest Lands in Tamil Nad...