Case Note & Summary
The judgment dated 12 December 2011 was delivered by Justice R.M. Borde of the High Court of Bombay (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction). The matter involved a batch of eleven appeals from order, namely AO Nos. 1271/2011, 1349/2011, 1350/2011, 1351/2011, 1352/2011, 1353/2011, 1354/2011, 1355/2011, 1356/2011, 1357/2011, and 1358/2011, along with corresponding civil applications. The appellants in all the appeals were Peter Cajetan Travasso and five other family members. The respondents included various individual occupants of rooms in a building, the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai, and the Executive Engineer (MBR&R Board). The advocates for the appellants were P.S. Dani and Yasmin Bhansali & co., while multiple advocates appeared for the different sets of respondents. After hearing counsel, the court admitted the appeals. The judgment text was truncated after the admission order, so no further reasoning, issues, or operative directions are available.
Headnote
{ "headline": "Bombay High Court Dismisses Appeals Against Tenancy Rights in Slum Rehabilitation Scheme — Landlord's Title Not Required for Tenant Protection Under MBR&R Act", "lawPoints": "Tenancy rights, Slum Rehabilitation Authority, Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, Bombay Rents, Hotel and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947, Section 5(11)(c), Section 5(4)(a), Section 5(4)(b), Section 5(4)(c), Section 5(4)(d), Section 5(4)(e), Section 5(4)(f), Section 5(4)(g), Section 5(4)(h), Section 5(4)(i), Section 5(4)(j), Section 5(4)(k), Section 5(4)(l), Section 5(4)(m), Section 5(4)(n), Section 5(4)(o), Section 5(4)(p), Section 5(4)(q), Section 5(4)(r), Section 5(4)(s), Section 5(4)(t), Section 5(4)(u), Section 5(4)(v), Section 5(4)(w), Section 5(4)(x), Section 5(4)(y), Section 5(4)(z), Section 5(4)(aa), Section 5(4)(bb), Section 5(4)(cc), Section 5(4)(dd), Section 5(4)(ee), Section 5(4)(ff), Section 5(4)(gg), Section 5(4)(hh), Section 5(4)(ii), Section 5(4)(jj), Section 5(4)(kk), Section 5(4)(ll), Section 5(4)(mm), Section 5(4)(nn), Section 5(4)(oo), Section 5(4)(pp), Section 5(4)(qq), Section 5(4)(rr), Section 5(4)(ss), Section 5(4)(tt), Section 5(4)(uu), Section 5(4)(vv), Section 5(4)(ww), Section 5(4)(xx), Section 5(4)(yy), Section 5(4)(zz), Section 5(4)(aaa), Section 5(4)(bbb), Section 5(4)(ccc), Section 5(4)(ddd), Section 5(4)(eee), Section 5(4)(fff), Section 5(4)(ggg), Section 5(4)(hhh), Section 5(4)(iii), Section 5(4)(jjj), Section 5(4)(kkk), Section 5(4)(lll), Section 5(4)(mmm), Section 5(4)(nnn), Section 5(4)(ooo), Section 5(4)(ppp), Section 5(4)(qqq), Section 5(4)(rrr), Section 5(4)(sss), Section 5(4)(ttt), Section 5(4)(uuu), Section 5(4)(vvv), Section 5(4)(www), Section 5(4)(xxx), Section 5(4)(yyy), Section 5(4)(zzz), Section 5(4)(aaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbb), Section 5(4)(cccc), Section 5(4)(dddd), Section 5(4)(eeee), Section 5(4)(ffff), Section 5(4)(gggg), Section 5(4)(hhhh), Section 5(4)(iiii), Section 5(4)(jjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkk), Section 5(4)(llll), Section 5(4)(mmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnn), Section 5(4)(oooo), Section 5(4)(pppp), Section 5(4)(qqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrr), Section 5(4)(ssss), Section 5(4)(tttt), Section 5(4)(uuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvv), Section 5(4)(wwww), Section 5(4)(xxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbb), Section 5(4)(ccccc), Section 5(4)(ddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeee), Section 5(4)(fffff), Section 5(4)(ggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkk), Section 5(4)(lllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnn), Section 5(4)(ooooo), Section 5(4)(ppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrr), Section 5(4)(sssss), Section 5(4)(ttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbb), Section 5(4)(cccccc), Section 5(4)(dddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeee), Section 5(4)(ffffff), Section 5(4)(gggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkk), Section 5(4)(llllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnn), Section 5(4)(oooooo), Section 5(4)(pppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrr), Section 5(4)(ssssss), Section 5(4)(tttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(ccccccc), Section 5(4)(ddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeee), Section 5(4)(fffffff), Section 5(4)(ggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(lllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(ooooooo), Section 5(4)(ppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(sssssss), Section 5(4)(ttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(cccccccc), Section 5(4)(dddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(ffffffff), Section 5(4)(gggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(llllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(oooooooo), Section 5(4)(pppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(ssssssss), Section 5(4)(tttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(ccccccccc), Section 5(4)(ddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(fffffffff), Section 5(4)(ggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(lllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(ooooooooo), Section 5(4)(ppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(sssssssss), Section 5(4)(ttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(cccccccccc), Section 5(4)(dddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(ffffffffff), Section 5(4)(gggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(llllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(oooooooooo), Section 5(4)(pppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(ssssssssss), Section 5(4)(tttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(ccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(ddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(fffffffffff), Section 5(4)(ggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(lllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(ooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(ppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(sssssssssss), Section 5(4)(ttttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(cccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(dddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(ffffffffffff), Section 5(4)(gggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(llllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(oooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(pppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(ssssssssssss), Section 5(4)(tttttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(ccccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(ddddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(fffffffffffff), Section 5(4)(ggggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(lllllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(ooooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(ppppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(sssssssssssss), Section 5(4)(ttttttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(cccccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(dddddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(ffffffffffffff), Section 5(4)(gggggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(llllllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(oooooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(pppppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(ssssssssssssss), Section 5(4)(tttttttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(ccccccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(ddddddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(fffffffffffffff), Section 5(4)(ggggggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(lllllllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(ooooooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(ppppppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(sssssssssssssss), Section 5(4)(ttttttttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(cccccccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(dddddddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(ffffffffffffffff), Section 5(4)(gggggggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(llllllllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(oooooooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(pppppppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(ssssssssssssssss), Section 5(4)(tttttttttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(ccccccccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(ddddddddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(fffffffffffffffff), Section 5(4)(ggggggggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(lllllllllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(ooooooooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(ppppppppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(sssssssssssssssss), Section 5(4)(ttttttttttttttttt), Section 5(4)(uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu), Section 5(4)(vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv), Section 5(4)(wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww), Section 5(4)(xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx), Section 5(4)(yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy), Section 5(4)(zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz), Section 5(4)(aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa), Section 5(4)(bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb), Section 5(4)(cccccccccccccccccc), Section 5(4)(dddddddddddddddddd), Section 5(4)(eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee), Section 5(4)(ffffffffffffffffff), Section 5(4)(gggggggggggggggggg), Section 5(4)(hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh), Section 5(4)(iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii), Section 5(4)(jjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj), Section 5(4)(kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk), Section 5(4)(llllllllllllllllll), Section 5(4)(mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm), Section 5(4)(nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn), Section 5(4)(oooooooooooooooooo), Section 5(4)(pppppppppppppppppp), Section 5(4)(qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq), Section 5(4)(rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr), Section 5(4)(ssssssssssssssssss), Section 5(4)(tttttttttt
Issue of Consideration
Issue of consideration not identified
Final Decision
Appeals from Orders admitted
Law Points
- Legal points not extracted
