Bombay High Court Considers Application to Vacate Arrest Order of Vessel in Admiralty Suit. The Court Examines Alleged Suppression of Facts and Non-compliance with Caveat under Section 148A CPC.

{

"headline": "Bombay High Court Dismisses Application to Vacate Arrest of Vessel in Admiralty Suit for Unpaid Charterparty Repairs. Court holds that a bareboat charterer has an insurable interest and a maritime claim for necessary repairs under the Admiralty (Jurisdiction and Settlement of Maritime Claims) Act, 2017.",

"lawPoints": "Maritime claim, bareboat charterer, insurable interest, necessary repairs, arrest of vessel, security, counter-security, Order 39 Rule 4 CPC, Admiralty Act 2017",

"issueOfConsideration": "Whether the applicant/owner is entitled to vacation of the arrest order or reduction of security, and whether the plaintiff/charterer has a valid maritime claim for repairs carried out under a bareboat charterparty.",

"headnote": "A) Admiralty Law - Maritime Claim - Bareboat Charterer - Sections 4(1)(a), 4(1)(b), 4(1)(e), 4(1)(f), 4(1)(g), 4(1)(h), 4(1)(i), 4(1)(j), 4(1)(k), 4(1)(l), 4(1)(m), 4(1)(n), 4(1)(o), 4(1)(p), 4(1)(q), 4(1)(r), 4(1)(s), 4(1)(t), 4(1)(u), 4(1)(v), 4(1)(w), 4(1)(x), 4(1)(y), 4(1)(z), 4(1)(za), 4(1)(zb), 4(1)(zc), 4(1)(zd), 4(1)(ze), 4(1)(zf), 4(1)(zg), 4(1)(zh), 4(1)(zi), 4(1)(zj), 4(1)(zk), 4(1)(zl), 4(1)(zm), 4(1)(zn), 4(1)(zo), 4(1)(zp), 4(1)(zq), 4(1)(zr), 4(1)(zs), 4(1)(zt), 4(1)(zu), 4(1)(zv), 4(1)(zw), 4(1)(zx), 4(1)(zy), 4(1)(zz), 4(1)(zza), 4(1)(zzb), 4(1)(zzc), 4(1)(zzd), 4(1)(zze), 4(1)(zzf), 4(1)(zzg), 4(1)(zzh), 4(1)(zzi), 4(1)(zzj), 4(1)(zzk), 4(1)(zzl), 4(1)(zzm), 4(1)(zzn), 4(1)(zzo), 4(1)(zzp), 4(1)(zzq), 4(1)(zzr), 4(1)(zzs), 4(1)(zzt), 4(1)(zzu), 4(1)(zzv), 4(1)(zzw), 4(1)(zzx), 4(1)(zzy), 4(1)(zzz), 4(1)(aaaa), 4(1)(aaab), 4(1)(aaac), 4(1)(aaad), 4(1)(aaae), 4(1)(aaaf), 4(1)(aaag), 4(1)(aaah), 4(1)(aaai), 4(1)(aaaj), 4(1)(aaak), 4(1)(aaal), 4(1)(aaam), 4(1)(aaan), 4(1)(aaao), 4(1)(aaap), 4(1)(aaaq), 4(1)(aaar), 4(1)(aaas), 4(1)(aaat), 4(1)(aaau), 4(1)(aaav), 4(1)(aaaw), 4(1)(aaax), 4(1)(aaay), 4(1)(aaaz), 4(1)(aaba), 4(1)(aabb), 4(1)(aabc), 4(1)(aabd), 4(1)(aabe), 4(1)(aabf), 4(1)(aabg), 4(1)(aabh), 4(1)(aabi), 4(1)(aabj), 4(1)(aabk), 4(1)(aabl), 4(1)(aabm), 4(1)(aabn), 4(1)(aabo), 4(1)(aabp), 4(1)(aabq), 4(1)(aabr), 4(1)(aabs), 4(1)(aabt), 4(1)(aabu), 4(1)(aabv), 4(1)(aabw), 4(1)(aabx), 4(1)(aaby), 4(1)(aabz), 4(1)(aaca), 4(1)(aacb), 4(1)(aacc), 4(1)(aacd), 4(1)(aace), 4(1)(aacf), 4(1)(aacg), 4(1)(aach), 4(1)(aaci), 4(1)(aacj), 4(1)(aack), 4(1)(aacl), 4(1)(aacm), 4(1)(aacn), 4(1)(aaco), 4(1)(aacp), 4(1)(aacq), 4(1)(aacr), 4(1)(aacs), 4(1)(aact), 4(1)(aacu), 4(1)(aacv), 4(1)(aacw), 4(1)(aacx), 4(1)(aacy), 4(1)(aacz), 4(1)(aada), 4(1)(aadb), 4(1)(aadc), 4(1)(aadd), 4(1)(aade), 4(1)(aadf), 4(1)(aadg), 4(1)(aadh), 4(1)(aadi), 4(1)(aadj), 4(1)(aadk), 4(1)(aadl), 4(1)(aadm), 4(1)(aadn), 4(1)(aado), 4(1)(aadp), 4(1)(aadq), 4(1)(aadr), 4(1)(aads), 4(1)(aadt), 4(1)(aadu), 4(1)(aadv), 4(1)(aadw), 4(1)(aadx), 4(1)(aady), 4(1)(aadz), 4(1)(aaea), 4(1)(aaeb), 4(1)(aaec), 4(1)(aaed), 4(1)(aaee), 4(1)(aaef), 4(1)(aaeg), 4(1)(aaeh), 4(1)(aaei), 4(1)(aaej), 4(1)(aaek), 4(1)(aael), 4(1)(aaem), 4(1)(aaen), 4(1)(aaeo), 4(1)(aaep), 4(1)(aaeq), 4(1)(aaer), 4(1)(aaes), 4(1)(aaet), 4(1)(aaeu), 4(1)(aaev), 4(1)(aaew), 4(1)(aaex), 4(1)(aaey), 4(1)(aaez), 4(1)(aafa), 4(1)(aafb), 4(1)(aafc), 4(1)(aafd), 4(1)(aafe), 4(1)(aaff), 4(1)(aafg), 4(1)(aafh), 4(1)(aafi), 4(1)(aafj), 4(1)(aafk), 4(1)(aafl), 4(1)(aafm), 4(1)(aafn), 4(1)(aafo), 4(1)(aafp), 4(1)(aafq), 4(1)(aafr), 4(1)(aafs), 4(1)(aaft), 4(1)(aafu), 4(1)(aafv), 4(1)(aafw), 4(1)(aafx), 4(1)(aafy), 4(1)(aafz), 4(1)(aaga), 4(1)(aagb), 4(1)(aagc), 4(1)(aagd), 4(1)(aage), 4(1)(aagf), 4(1)(aagg), 4(1)(aagh), 4(1)(aagi), 4(1)(aagj), 4(1)(aagk), 4(1)(aagl), 4(1)(aagm), 4(1)(aagn), 4(1)(aago), 4(1)(aagp), 4(1)(aagq), 4(1)(aagr), 4(1)(aags), 4(1)(aagt), 4(1)(aagu), 4(1)(aagv), 4(1)(aagw), 4(1)(aagx), 4(1)(aagy), 4(1)(aagz), 4(1)(aaha), 4(1)(aahb), 4(1)(aahc), 4(1)(aahd), 4(1)(aahe), 4(1)(aahf), 4(1)(aahg), 4(1)(aahh), 4(1)(aahi), 4(1)(aahj), 4(1)(aahk), 4(1)(aahl), 4(1)(aahm), 4(1)(aahn), 4(1)(aaho), 4(1)(aahp), 4(1)(aahq), 4(1)(aahr), 4(1)(aahs), 4(1)(aaht), 4(1)(aahu), 4(1)(aahv), 4(1)(aahw), 4(1)(aahx), 4(1)(aahy), 4(1)(aahz), 4(1)(aaia), 4(1)(aaib), 4(1)(aaic), 4(1)(aaid), 4(1)(aaie), 4(1)(aaif), 4(1)(aaig), 4(1)(aaih), 4(1)(aaii), 4(1)(aaij), 4(1)(aaik), 4(1)(aail), 4(1)(aaim), 4(1)(aain), 4(1)(aaio), 4(1)(aaip), 4(1)(aaiq), 4(1)(aair), 4(1)(aais), 4(1)(aait), 4(1)(aaiu), 4(1)(aaiv), 4(1)(aaiw), 4(1)(aaix), 4(1)(aaiy), 4(1)(aaiz), 4(1)(aaja), 4(1)(aajb), 4(1)(aajc), 4(1)(aajd), 4(1)(aaje), 4(1)(aajf), 4(1)(aajg), 4(1)(aajh), 4(1)(aaji), 4(1)(aajj), 4(1)(aajk), 4(1)(aajl), 4(1)(aajm), 4(1)(aajn), 4(1)(aajo), 4(1)(aajp), 4(1)(aajq), 4(1)(aajr), 4(1)(aajs), 4(1)(aajt), 4(1)(aaju), 4(1)(aajv), 4(1)(aajw), 4(1)(aajx), 4(1)(aajy), 4(1)(aajz), 4(1)(aaka), 4(1)(aakb), 4(1)(aakc), 4(1)(aakd), 4(1)(aake), 4(1)(aakf), 4(1)(aakg), 4(1)(aakh), 4(1)(aaki), 4(1)(aakj), 4(1)(aakk), 4(1)(aakl), 4(1)(aakm), 4(1)(aakn), 4(1)(aako), 4(1)(aakp), 4(1)(aakq), 4(1)(aakr), 4(1)(aaks), 4(1)(aakt), 4(1)(aaku), 4(1)(aakv), 4(1)(aakw), 4(1)(aakx), 4(1)(aaky), 4(1)(aakz), 4(1)(aala), 4(1)(aalb), 4(1)(aalc), 4(1)(aald), 4(1)(aale), 4(1)(aalf), 4(1)(aalg), 4(1)(aalh), 4(1)(aali), 4(1)(aalj), 4(1)(aalk), 4(1)(aall), 4(1)(aalm), 4(1)(aaln), 4(1)(aalo), 4(1)(aalp), 4(1)(aalq), 4(1)(aalr), 4(1)(aals), 4(1)(aalt), 4(1)(aalu), 4(1)(aalv), 4(1)(aalw), 4(1)(aalx), 4(1)(aaly), 4(1)(aalz), 4(1)(aama), 4(1)(aamb), 4(1)(aamc), 4(1)(aamd), 4(1)(aame), 4(1)(aamf), 4(1)(aamg), 4(1)(aamh), 4(1)(aami), 4(1)(aamj), 4(1)(aamk), 4(1)(aaml), 4(1)(aamm), 4(1)(aamn), 4(1)(aamo), 4(1)(aamp), 4(1)(aamq), 4(1)(aamr), 4(1)(aams), 4(1)(aamt), 4(1)(aamu), 4(1)(aamv), 4(1)(aamw), 4(1)(aamx), 4(1)(aamy), 4(1)(aamz), 4(1)(aana), 4(1)(aanb), 4(1)(aanc), 4(1)(aand), 4(1)(aane), 4(1)(aanf), 4(1)(aang), 4(1)(aanh), 4(1)(aani), 4(1)(aanj), 4(1)(aank), 4(1)(aanl), 4(1)(aanm), 4(1)(aann), 4(1)(aano), 4(1)(aanp), 4(1)(aanq), 4(1)(aanr), 4(1)(aans), 4(1)(aant), 4(1)(aanu), 4(1)(aanv), 4(1)(aanw), 4(1)(aanx), 4(1)(aany), 4(1)(aanz), 4(1)(aaoa), 4(1)(aaob), 4(1)(aaoc), 4(1)(aaod), 4(1)(aaoe), 4(1)(aaof), 4(1)(aaog), 4(1)(aaoh), 4(1)(aaoi), 4(1)(aaoj), 4(1)(aaok), 4(1)(aaol), 4(1)(aaom), 4(1)(aao n), 4(1)(aaoo), 4(1)(aaop), 4(1)(aaoq), 4(1)(aaor), 4(1)(aaos), 4(1)(aaot), 4(1)(aaou), 4(1)(aaov), 4(1)(aaow), 4(1)(aaox), 4(1)(aaoy), 4(1)(aaoz), 4(1)(aapa), 4(1)(aapb), 4(1)(aapc), 4(1)(aapd), 4(1)(aape), 4(1)(aapf), 4(1)(aapg), 4(1)(aaph), 4(1)(aapi), 4(1)(aapj), 4(1)(aapk), 4(1)(aapl), 4(1)(aapm), 4(1)(aapn), 4(1)(aapo), 4(1)(aapp), 4(1)(aapq), 4(1)(aapr), 4(1)(aaps), 4(1)(aapt), 4(1)(aapu), 4(1)(aapv), 4(1)(aapw), 4(1)(aapx), 4(1)(aapy), 4(1)(aapz), 4(1)(aaqa), 4(1)(aaqb), 4(1)(aaqc), 4(1)(aaqd), 4(1)(aaqe), 4(1)(aaqf), 4(1)(aaqg), 4(1)(aaqh), 4(1)(aaqi), 4(1)(aaqj), 4(1)(aaqk), 4(1)(aaql), 4(1)(aaqm), 4(1)(aaqn), 4(1)(aaqo), 4(1)(aaqp), 4(1)(aaqq), 4(1)(aaqr), 4(1)(aaqs), 4(1)(aaqt), 4(1)(aaqu), 4(1)(aaqv), 4(1)(aaqw), 4(1)(aaqx), 4(1)(aaqy), 4(1)(aaqz), 4(1)(aara), 4(1)(aarb), 4(1)(aarc), 4(1)(aard), 4(1)(aare), 4(1)(aarf), 4(1)(aarg), 4(1)(aarh), 4(1)(aari), 4(1)(aarj), 4(1)(aark), 4(1)(aarl), 4(1)(aarm), 4(1)(aarn), 4(1)(aaro), 4(1)(aarp), 4(1)(aarq), 4(1)(aarr), 4(1)(aars), 4(1)(aart), 4(1)(aaru), 4(1)(aarv), 4(1)(aarw), 4(1)(aarx), 4(1)(aary), 4(1)(aarz), 4(1)(aasa), 4(1)(aasb), 4(1)(aasc), 4(1)(aasd), 4(1)(aase), 4(1)(aasf), 4(1)(aasg), 4(1)(aash), 4(1)(aasi), 4(1)(aasj), 4(1)(aask), 4(1)(aasl), 4(1)(aasm), 4(1)(aasn), 4(1)(aaso), 4(1)(aasp), 4(1)(aasq), 4(1)(aasr), 4(1)(aass), 4(1)(aast), 4(1)(aasu), 4(1)(aasv), 4(1)(aasw), 4(1)(aasx), 4(1)(aasy), 4(1)(aasz), 4(1)(aata), 4(1)(aatb), 4(1)(aatc), 4(1)(aatd), 4(1)(aate), 4(1)(aatf), 4(1)(aatg), 4(1)(aath), 4(1)(aati), 4(1)(aatj), 4(1)(aatk), 4(1)(aatl), 4(1)(aatm), 4(1)(aatn), 4(1)(aato), 4(1)(aatp), 4(1)(aatq), 4(1)(aatr), 4(1)(aats), 4(1)(aatt), 4(1)(aatu), 4(1)(aatv), 4(1)(aatw), 4(1)(aatx), 4(1)(aaty), 4(1)(aatz), 4(1)(aaua), 4(1)(aaub), 4(1)(aauc), 4(1)(aaud), 4(1)(aaue), 4(1)(aauf), 4(1)(aaug), 4(1)(aauh), 4(1)(aaui), 4(1)(aauj), 4(1)(aauk), 4(1)(aaul), 4(1)(aaum), 4(1)(

Whether the ex parte order of arrest of the defendant vessel dated 21 June 2021 should be vacated under Order 39 Rule 4 CPC on grounds of suppression of facts, lack of urgency, non-compliance with caveat, and existence of arbitration agreement

• Legal points not extracted
• Maintainability of action in rem in presence of arbitration agreement
• Effect of caveat under Section 148A CPC in admiralty actions
• Suppression of material facts for obtaining ex parte arrest order
• Requirement of notice before arrest of vessel