Case Note & Summary
The Supreme Court of India addressed the Special Leave Petitions filed by the State of U.P. against interim orders of the High Court regarding the construction of a new High Court building. The High Court had directed the State Government to submit a status report on funding for the construction, which led to the State's grievances about the procedural handling of the matter. The original writ petition was filed by Dr. Neeraj Chaubey concerning eligibility criteria for an Assistant Professor position, which was set at seven years instead of the statutory five years. The Supreme Court noted the importance of the High Court's need for a new building but raised concerns about the procedural legitimacy of the High Court's actions, which treated the matter as a Public Interest Litigation without proper allocation of jurisdiction. The court referenced a Full Bench decision of the High Court affirming that the Chief Justice has the authority to manage case assignments and that adherence to this procedure is crucial for judicial discipline. The Supreme Court permitted the State to file an application before the Chief Justice for appropriate directions and stayed the order requiring officials to appear in court. The court concluded that the Oudh Bar Association could also file a petition regarding the construction issue. The Special Leave Petitions were disposed of accordingly.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Judicial Procedure - Authority of Chief Justice - States Re-organisation Act, 1956, Section 51(3) - The court emphasized that the Chief Justice has the exclusive authority to allocate cases and manage judicial business, ensuring judicial discipline and proper functioning of the court. The court held that deviations from this procedure are impermissible and that any public interest matters should be properly assigned to the appropriate bench. (Paras 5-6).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the directions issued by the High Court regarding the construction of a new High Court building were appropriate and followed proper judicial procedure.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court granted permission for the State of U.P. to file an application before the Chief Justice for appropriate directions and stayed the order requiring officials to appear in court.
Law Points
- Judicial discipline
- Public Interest Litigation
- Chief Justice's authority
- High Court procedures



