Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from an agreement between the appellant and the State of Andhra Pradesh regarding the Ongole Water Supply Improvement Scheme. The appellant lodged claims for payment under the contract, which the State did not settle, leading to the appellant seeking arbitration. The Sub-ordinate Judge appointed an arbitrator, which the State did not challenge at that time. The arbitrator issued an award favoring the appellant, which the State later sought to set aside, arguing that claims over Rs. 50,000 should be resolved in civil court, not through arbitration. The High Court agreed with the State, leading to the current appeal. The Supreme Court examined whether the GOM dated 24.10.1983 allowed for arbitration for claims above Rs. 50,000 and whether the State could challenge the appointment of the arbitrator after participating in the proceedings. The court found that the GOM did not permit arbitration for such claims and that the State had waived its right to contest the arbitrator's appointment by participating in the arbitration without objection. The court restored the order appointing the arbitrator and remanded the case for fresh consideration of the State's challenge to the award. The decision emphasized the importance of finality in judicial orders and the consequences of participating in proceedings without objection.
Headnote
A) Arbitration Law - Arbitration Agreement - Existence of Arbitration Agreement - Arbitration Act, 1940, Section 8 - The court held that the order appointing an arbitrator was valid as the first respondent participated in the arbitration proceedings without raising objections regarding the arbitration agreement, thus accepting its existence. The court emphasized that the first respondent could not later challenge the appointment of the arbitrator after the award was made. (Paras 12-19). B) Government Orders - Claims Above Rs. 50000 - Applicability of GOM - Arbitration Act, 1940, Section 8 - The court clarified that the GOM dated 24.10.1983 did not provide for arbitration for claims exceeding Rs. 50000, and the subsequent GOM clarified this position. The court held that the earlier interpretation allowing arbitration for such claims was incorrect. (Paras 10-11).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the GOM dated 24.10.1983 provided for arbitration and whether the order appointing an arbitrator could be challenged after participation in arbitration proceedings.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals, set aside the High Court's order dated 5.10.1999, restored the order dated 25.3.1991 appointing the arbitrator, and remanded the case for fresh consideration of the State's challenge to the award.
Law Points
- arbitration agreement
- jurisdiction of arbitrator
- claims above Rs. 50000
- Government Orders
- finality of court orders



