Acts and Sections Discussed:
Constitution of India, Article 14 – Equality before Law
Odisha Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1992 – Rule 18 and its Amendments
Orissa Consolidation of Holdings and Prevention of Fragmentation of Land Act, 1972
Subjects:
Pension Benefits, Job Contract Employees, Procedural Delay, Judicial Discipline, Administrative Efficiency, Service Rules, Financial Implications, Legal Precedents, Governance Accountability
Facts:
Nature of Litigation: The State of Odisha challenged the Orissa High Court’s Division Bench order dismissing their Writ Appeals due to inordinate delay.
Remedy Sought: The State requested the Supreme Court to examine the merits of the case despite procedural lapses.
Reason for Filing: The State sought to reverse decisions extending pension benefits to job contract employees, claiming misinterpretation of service rules.
Previous Decisions: Orissa High Court and Administrative Tribunal judgments had favored employees, allowing the counting of job contract service for pension eligibility.
Issues:
a) Whether the entire period of job contract employment should be considered for pensionary benefits. b) Whether the State’s delayed filing justified the dismissal of its appeals. c) Whether the distinction between job contract and workcharged employees violates Article 14 of the Constitution.
d) Whether the amended Odisha Pension Rules, 1992 adequately addressed the pension eligibility of job contract employees.
Submissions/Arguments:
Appellants (State of Odisha): Argued procedural lapses and misinterpretation of legal provisions by lower courts.
Respondents (Employees): Emphasized fairness, established precedents, and the need for pension eligibility considering long years of service.
Decision:
The Supreme Court condoned the delay and accepted the appeals given the importance of the matter.
It reaffirmed the limited counting of job contract service for pension as per the Odisha Pension Rules, 1992.
The Court criticized the State’s lethargic approach and imposed costs for delayed filings.
Ratio Decidendi:
Procedural discipline and timely governance are essential for fair adjudication.
Judicial intervention is warranted when administrative inefficiency leads to injustice.
The distinction between workcharged and job contract employees is valid under existing service rules unless challenged on constitutional grounds.
Citation: 2025 LawText (SC) (2) 211
Case Number: [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2146 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4655 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4401 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2196 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2120 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2426 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 3352 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 3400 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2335 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2226 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2334 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 2903 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4527 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6223 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 5151 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6355 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6209 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4402 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4656 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4792 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4789 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4688 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4788 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6087 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4687 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4438 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 202 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 6393 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 4766 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 5720 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6258 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 7382 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6567 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6268 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6133 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6356 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 5502 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 5548 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6434 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6435 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 9601 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 9602 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 9603 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 8435 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 9282 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10042 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 5656 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6347 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7794 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6007 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10250 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6166 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7791 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7792 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6075 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6171 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7963 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7964 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6392 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7967 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7796 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7797 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7966 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7246 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10088 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6353 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7811 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7812 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7143 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7965 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7874 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7798 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7799 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 8433 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7803 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7983 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7984 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 6191 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7978 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7982 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 8434 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7618 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10085 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 8431 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 7981 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 8432 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10649 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10084 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 9283 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10644 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10645 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 9284 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 9087 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10643 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10992 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10650 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10083 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10082 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10646 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12297 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11598 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 19369 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17756 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12294 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10993 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11578 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12288 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11573 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11579 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10991 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11455 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10994 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11456 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11570 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11572 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12301 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12302 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12837 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11576 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11577 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12296 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12309 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11575 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12295 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11569 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 10995 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11581 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11571 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11574 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 11580 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15687 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12304 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12310 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12300 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12311 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12305 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12307 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12308 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 12306 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15686 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15481 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15480 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15508 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 18301 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17830 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 18299 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15717 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15749 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 18300 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17824 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17821 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17816 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17811 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17818 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17814 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 16559 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17815 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15441 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17806 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15683 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17822 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15672 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15685 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17881 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15510 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15511 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15479 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15509 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17889 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17893 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17819 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17879 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15720 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15513 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17873 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17825 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17885 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15512 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17877 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17895 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17899 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15531 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15533 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15530 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15534 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17876 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17875 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17883 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15536 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15746 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15745 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17829 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 18298 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17817 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15463 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17826 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17880 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17902 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15744 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 15535 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17882 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17820 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17884 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17823 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17813 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17878 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17898 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17827 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 17874 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 19408 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20509 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20508 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20561 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20563 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20560 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20562 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20565 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20557 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20558 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20559 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20556 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 20343 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 23885 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 24310 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28961 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30646 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 5977 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 18515 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 27167 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28274 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28760 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28774 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28938 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28966 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 29318 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30401 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30627 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30628 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 31073 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 32950 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 32970 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 33072 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 33271 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 33441 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 19599 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 24429 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 12264 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 20764 of 2023] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 24149 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 27173 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28237 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 35149 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 35545 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 35585 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 23891 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 25624 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28247 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28971 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 31463 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 34339 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 35346 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 22385 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S). 22956 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 31709 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 35341 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30652 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 31345 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 31428 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 31727 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 22415 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 22412 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28595 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 38231 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 16750 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 21676 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28967 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 42121 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 38061 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 28235 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30169 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 35336 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 20431 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 24360 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 14156 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 21155 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 21715 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 22022 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 23918 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30987 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 9851 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 11039 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 14172 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 20077 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30976 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30984 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 34856 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 27334 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 45705 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 32613 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 44816 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No.________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No. 26163 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 27347 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 47660 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 30968 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 47650 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 49054 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 50190 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 26406 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 50203 of 2024] [Civil Appeal No(S).________ of 2025 @ SLP (Civil) No(S).________ of 2025 Diary No. 27568 of 2024]
Date of Decision: 2025-02-21
Case Title: STATE OF ODISHA & ORS. VERSUS SUDHANSU SEKHAR JENA
Before Judge: [Sudhanshu Dhulia J. , Ahsanuddin Amanullah J.]
Appellant: STATE OF ODISHA & ORS.
Respondent: SUDHANSU SEKHAR JENA
