Supreme Court Rejects Petition for Compassionate Appointment Post-Retirement Due to Ineligibility. Request for compassionate appointment denied as the father did not die in harness and the application was made after his death.

  • 5
Judgement Image
Font size:
Print

Case Note & Summary

The dispute arose from the case of Shiv Nath Mahto, a Translator-cum-Proof Reader, who was compulsorily retired by the State Government in June 2007 under Rule 74 of the Bihar Service Code, effective from July 1, 2007. He passed away on September 20, 2008. Following his death, his widow, Manti Devi, claimed that the retirement was illegal and sought compassionate appointment for her elder son due to the family's financial distress. After her representation went unanswered, she filed a Writ Petition in the Patna High Court, which was dismissed by a Single Judge on July 29, 2011, and subsequently by a Division Bench on October 25, 2011. Manti Devi later passed away, leading to the present Special Leave Petition (SLP) filed by her children. The court noted that the deceased employee did not object to his retirement until his death, and he had acknowledged his illness leading to the retirement. The court emphasized that the request for compassionate appointment was made posthumously and that the elder son was already 35 years old, making him ineligible for such relief. Ultimately, the SLP was rejected, affirming the lower court's decisions and the rationale behind the denial of compassionate appointment.

Headnote

A) Employment Law - Compassionate Appointment - Eligibility Criteria - Bihar Service Code, 2007, Rule 74 - The court held that compassionate appointment cannot be granted to a person whose father died after compulsory retirement, as the father did not die in harness. The petitioner's father had accepted his retirement due to illness, and the request for appointment was made only after his death, indicating no immediate need for support at the time of retirement. Held that the petition lacked merit (Paras 2-5).

Subscribe to unlock Headnote Subscribe Now

Issue of Consideration

Whether the elder son of the deceased employee is entitled to compassionate appointment after the father's compulsory retirement and subsequent death.

Subscribe to unlock Issue of Consideration Subscribe Now

Final Decision

The Supreme Court rejected the Special Leave Petition, affirming that compassionate appointment could not be granted as the father had not died in harness and the request was made posthumously.

Law Points

  • Compassionate appointment
  • compulsory retirement
  • public interest
  • legal standing of dependents
Subscribe to unlock Law Points Subscribe Now

Case Details

2013 LawText (SC) (11) 26

Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 3962 of 2012

2013-11-21

A.K. Sikri, K.S. Radhakrishnan

Children of Manti Devi and deceased employee

State of Bihar & Ors.

Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more) Subscribe Now

Nature of Litigation

Challenge to the legality of compulsory retirement and request for compassionate appointment.

Remedy Sought

Compassionate appointment for the elder son of the deceased employee.

Filing Reason

Claim of illegal retirement and financial distress after the death of the employee.

Previous Decisions

Writ Petition dismissed by the High Court; Intra Court Appeal also dismissed.

Issues

Eligibility for compassionate appointment post-retirement Legality of compulsory retirement

Submissions/Arguments

Petitioner argued for compassionate appointment due to financial distress. Respondent maintained that the father did not die in harness and the request was made after his death.

Ratio Decidendi

Compassionate appointment is not available to dependents of employees who die after compulsory retirement, as they are not considered to have died in harness.

Judgment Excerpts

Compulsory retirement was made effective from 30th June 2007. The elder son is about 35 years of age.

Procedural History

The case began with the compulsory retirement of Shiv Nath Mahto in June 2007, followed by his death in September 2008. Manti Devi filed a representation in November 2008, which led to a Writ Petition dismissed in July 2011, and an Intra Court Appeal dismissed in October 2011. The present SLP was filed after Manti Devi's death.

Acts & Sections

  • Bihar Service Code: Rule 74
Subscribe to unlock full Legal Analysis Subscribe Now
Related Judgement
High Court Bombay High Court Dismisses Workers' Appeals in Industrial Dispute — Upholds Single Judge's Order Setting Aside Reinstatement. Allegations of Vague Charge-Sheet and Discrimination Rejected as Inquiry Found Fair and Punishment Proportionate.
Related Judgement
Supreme Court Supreme Court Cancels Bail in IPC Forgery Case Due to Material Suppression and Witness Intimidation -- Appellant's Appeal Against High Court's Bail Order Upheld as Accused Concealed Multiple FIRs and Abused Liberty