Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the allotment of a site in Mysore to the appellant, the widow of the original allottee, S. Ramakrishna. The site was allotted under the general category, and while the husband made part payment, the full amount was not paid within the stipulated time. Following the husband's death in May 1994, the appellant applied for the allotment to be transferred to her name, which was accepted in March 1998. However, due to an error, she paid only Rs.5000 instead of the required Rs.7343, leading to a notice from the Mysore Urban Development Authority in January 2005 regarding the unpaid balance. The appellant's request for an extension to make the payment was rejected in November 2006, resulting in the cancellation of the allotment. The appellant challenged this cancellation through a writ petition in 2010, which was dismissed due to her lack of diligence in payment and the significant time elapsed since the allotment. The dismissal was upheld in a writ appeal in January 2011, with the court noting her failure to establish her claim of belonging to a backward community. The appellant subsequently filed a Special Leave Petition, leading to the current appeal. The Supreme Court acknowledged the appellant's circumstances as an illiterate widow with two minor children and noted that the site was still available. In a humanitarian decision, the Court directed the regularization of the site in her name, requiring payment of the outstanding amount with interest within three months, while clarifying that this order was not to set a precedent for future cases.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Allotment of Land - Non-Payment of Consideration - Article 142 of the Constitution of India - The appellant, an illiterate widow, was denied relief due to non-payment of the full consideration amount for a site allotted to her late husband. However, the Supreme Court exercised its jurisdiction under Article 142 to regularize the allotment on humanitarian grounds, directing payment of the balance amount with interest (Paras 5-6).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the appellant was entitled to relief for the allotment of the site despite non-payment of the full consideration amount.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court directed the regularization of the site in the appellant's name, requiring payment of the outstanding amount with interest within three months, while clarifying that this order was made on humanitarian grounds and should not set a precedent.
Law Points
- Discretionary jurisdiction
- allotment rules
- humanitarian grounds
- Article 142
- payment of dues


