Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the failure of the State of Bihar to appoint trained teachers in primary schools despite earlier commitments made in 2006. Several trained teachers filed Special Leave Petitions seeking directions for their appointment. The State had previously assured the Court of its intention to fill vacancies but failed to do so, leading to contempt petitions. The Court had previously directed the appointment of 34,540 trained teachers based on available vacancies. However, discrepancies in the eligibility of candidates and the select list emerged, prompting the appointment of a retired judge to finalize the list. After the list was accepted, further grievances arose from candidates who were not included. The Court allowed these grievances to be addressed in the High Court while ensuring that the appointments already made would not be disturbed. The Court disposed of all pending applications and petitions, emphasizing the need to consider the remaining vacancies for future appointments.
Headnote
A) Contempt of Court - Compliance with Undertakings - State's Commitment to Appoint Teachers - Supreme Court of India, 2013 - The State of Bihar failed to honor its commitment to appoint trained teachers as per earlier undertakings, leading to contempt petitions. The Court directed that grievances regarding the select list be addressed in the High Court while ensuring that already appointed teachers remain undisturbed. Held that the balance vacancies should be considered for filling (Paras 8-9).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the State of Bihar complied with its commitments regarding the appointment of trained teachers.
Final Decision
The Court disposed of all applications and petitions, allowing grievances to be addressed in the High Court while ensuring that the appointments already made would not be disturbed. The Court directed that the remaining vacancies be considered for future appointments.
Law Points
- Contempt of Court
- Teacher Recruitment
- Administrative Law
- Education Law



