Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the recruitment process for the posts of Computer Operator/Lab Assistant/System Administrator at the J&K Institute of Management Public Administration and Rural Development. The appellant published an advertisement on 15.1.2005 inviting applications for the vacancies. After the selection process, a select list was prepared, but Renu Bala, one of the candidates, was not selected and subsequently filed Writ Petition No.93 of 2005 challenging the selection procedure. The High Court's single judge found merit in her allegations that undue favour was given to another candidate, Ashok Kumar Koul, and directed the appellant to appoint Renu Bala. The appellant appealed this decision to the Division Bench, which upheld the single judge's findings but modified the Recruitment Rules and directed a fresh declaration of results. The appellant contended that the Division Bench had exceeded its jurisdiction by effectively rewriting the Recruitment Rules. The Supreme Court, upon reviewing the case, agreed that the High Court had overstepped its authority and quashed the Division Bench's judgment, reinstating the single judge's order while removing Ashok Kumar Koul from the select list. The Court directed that the next candidates in line be selected according to the existing Recruitment Rules, allowing Renu Bala to be appointed based on her position in the select list, subject to necessary formalities. The appeal was allowed with no order as to costs.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Jurisdiction of High Court - Exceeding Jurisdiction - High Court's authority to modify Recruitment Rules - The Division Bench of the High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by directing the appellant to amend the Recruitment Rules and declare results based on those modifications. The Supreme Court held that the learned single Judge was correct in identifying undue favour in the selection process and quashed the Division Bench's judgment (Paras 13-14).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the Division Bench of the High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by modifying the Recruitment Rules and directing the appellant to declare results based on those modifications.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, quashed the Division Bench's judgment, and reinstated the single judge's order, directing that the next candidates be selected according to the existing Recruitment Rules.
Law Points
- Jurisdiction of High Court
- Recruitment Rules
- Selection Procedure
- Writ Petition
- Modification of Rules



