Case Note & Summary
The case involved an appeal against a disciplinary action taken by M.G.B. Gramin Bank, where the appellant, Chhel Singh, was removed from service for unauthorized absence. The appellant had been employed as a Clerk-cum-Cashier since February 17, 1984, and was absent from duty for approximately 10 and a half months without prior permission, leading to a memorandum of charges against him. The appellant contested the charges, claiming serious illness during his absence, which was not accepted by the Disciplinary Authority. An inquiry was conducted, but the Inquiry Officer only called two of the seven defence witnesses proposed by the appellant, leading to a report that found the appellant guilty. The appellant's subsequent appeal to the High Court resulted in a ruling that quashed the removal order but directed a fresh inquiry. The Division Bench of the High Court acknowledged the inquiry's flaws but set aside the reinstatement order, prompting the appellant to appeal to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court found that the Division Bench erred in not reinstating the appellant, as the inquiry was indeed flawed due to the denial of the right to summon witnesses and the lack of evidence to discredit the medical certificates provided by the appellant. The court upheld the Single Judge's order for reinstatement and directed the Bank to implement this decision within four weeks. The appeal was allowed with no costs.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Disciplinary Proceedings - Violation of Natural Justice - Marwar Gramin Bank (Staff) Service Regulations, 1980 - The inquiry against the appellant was found to be vitiated due to the denial of the right to summon defence witnesses, leading to a quashing of the termination order. The court held that the absence of valid reasons to disbelieve the medical certificates submitted by the appellant further supported the reinstatement (Paras 8-16).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the inquiry conducted against the appellant was in violation of principles of natural justice and whether the appellant was entitled to reinstatement.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench's order and upheld the Single Judge's decision to reinstate the appellant, directing the Bank to implement the reinstatement within four weeks.
Law Points
- natural justice
- disciplinary proceedings
- service regulations
- inquiry officer's discretion
- reinstatement



