Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a property ownership issue involving a residential house at 34, Elliot Road, Kolkata, originally owned by three individuals, including Smt. Kanak Nahar. Following a consent decree in 1957, Smt. Kanak Nahar sought permission from the High Court to sell her one-fourth share to Javed Akhtar and Parvez Akhtar, who were purchasing the remaining three-fourths. The High Court granted this permission in 1984. However, Smt. Kanak Nahar later sold her share to Smt. Shamima Khanam, leading to a legal challenge from Javed Akhtar and Parvez Akhtar, who filed a suit for specific performance, claiming fraud had occurred. The trial court ruled in favor of Javed Akhtar and Parvez Akhtar, leading to an appeal by the heirs of Smt. Shamima Khanam. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the High Court's findings that there was an understanding for the sale between Smt. Kanak Nahar and the respondents, and that the sale to Shamima Khanam was invalid due to the lack of notice and the fraudulent nature of the transaction. The court emphasized that the property was indivisible, reinforcing the necessity for the sale to proceed as originally intended.
Headnote
A) Property Law - Specific Performance - Validity of Sale Deed - Specific Relief Act, 1963, Section 20 - The court upheld the High Court's decree for specific performance, finding that there was an understanding between Smt. Kanak Nahar and the respondents regarding the sale of her share, despite the sale to Shamima Khanam. The court noted that the property was indivisible, and the respondents had a legitimate interest in purchasing the remaining share (Paras 19-24).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the High Court's decree for specific performance in favor of Javed Akhtar and Parvez Akhtar was justified despite the sale of the property share to Shamima Khanam.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the High Court's decree for specific performance in favor of Javed Akhtar and Parvez Akhtar, concluding that there was an understanding for the sale of the property share.
Law Points
- specific performance
- consent decree
- fraud
- nominee
- property transfer



