Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose between the Dewan Sajjadanashin and Khadims of the Holy Shrine of Hazrat Khawaja Moinuddin Chishti regarding the sharing of Nazrana offered by pilgrims. The petitioners contended that the High Court exceeded its authority by framing a scheme for implementing a decree from 1933, which they believed was unwarranted. The petitioners, representing the Khadims, sought a permanent arrangement for implementing the decree due to ongoing disputes. The High Court proposed interim arrangements involving the Durgah Committee, which oversees the shrine's operations. The directions included the custody of offerings by the Nazim, the establishment of donation boxes, and the equitable distribution of offerings between the Dewan and Khadims. The petitioners raised objections to certain directions, arguing they were unworkable and disrupted customary practices. The Dewan and Durgah Committee supported the High Court's directions, emphasizing their fairness and the need for transparency. The Supreme Court, recognizing the importance of the shrine and the need for proper accounting, upheld the High Court's directions, vacating the status-quo order and allowing the implementation of the directions pending final adjudication. The court noted the necessity of cooperation among all parties to prevent disputes and ensure the shrine's effective functioning.
Headnote
A) Civil Procedure - Implementation of Decree - Directions for Management of Offerings - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - The High Court framed directions for the management of offerings at the Durgah, ensuring equitable distribution between Khadims and Dewan while maintaining transparency for pilgrims. The court upheld these directions, emphasizing the need for proper accounting and cooperation among all parties involved (Paras 1-13).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the directions issued by the High Court regarding the management of offerings at the Holy Shrine were warranted and equitable.
Final Decision
The Supreme Court upheld the High Court's directions for managing offerings at the shrine, emphasizing the need for transparency and equitable distribution among Khadims and Dewan, and vacated the status-quo order.
Law Points
- Equitable directions
- management of offerings
- Durgah Committee
- Khadims
- Dewan
- transparency in donations


