Supreme Court Commutes Death Sentence to Life Imprisonment Due to Inordinate Delay in Mercy Petition Disposal. The court found that the delay in processing the Mercy Petition and the conditions of solitary confinement violated the petitioner's rights under Article 21.

In Favour of Accused
  • 4
Judgement Image
Font size:
Print

Case Note & Summary

The case involved a writ petition filed under Article 32 of the Constitution of India by a petitioner seeking commutation of his death sentence to life imprisonment. The petitioner had been sentenced to death by the Special Judge, CBI, Ranchi on 09.04.2007, a decision that was upheld by the Jharkhand High Court on 28.08.2007 and subsequently by the Supreme Court on 16.03.2010. Following the confirmation of the death sentence, the petitioner submitted Mercy Petitions to the President of India and the Governor of Jharkhand on 10.04.2010, which were forwarded by the jail authorities on the same day. However, the Mercy Petition was not disposed of until 27.01.2014, leading to a delay of nearly three years and ten months. The petitioner argued that this delay, coupled with his prolonged solitary confinement since the imposition of the death sentence, constituted sufficient grounds for commutation. The court referenced previous judgments, including Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India, emphasizing that inordinate delays in the execution of death sentences could violate constitutional rights. The court found that the delay was solely attributable to the authorities and not the petitioner, thus constituting an infringement of his rights under Article 21. Additionally, the court noted that the petitioner had been wrongfully held in solitary confinement, as he was not under a final death sentence until the Mercy Petition was resolved. Ultimately, the court commuted the death sentence to life imprisonment, allowing the writ petition.

Headnote

A) Constitutional Law - Right to Life - Inordinate Delay in Mercy Petition Disposal - Article 32 of the Constitution of India - The court held that the delay of 3 years and 10 months in the disposal of the Mercy Petition constituted inordinate delay, justifying the commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment. The delay was attributed to the authorities, not the petitioner, thus violating his right under Article 21 (Paras 9-10).

B) Criminal Procedure - Solitary Confinement - Prisons Act, 1894, Section 30(2) - The court found that the petitioner was wrongfully kept in solitary confinement since the death sentence was awarded, as he was not under a finally executable sentence until the Mercy Petition was disposed of. This was deemed a transgression of his rights under Article 21 (Paras 10).

Subscribe to unlock Headnote Subscribe Now

Issue of Consideration

Whether the inordinate delay in the disposal of the Mercy Petition and the conditions of solitary confinement warranted commutation of the death sentence to life imprisonment.

Subscribe to unlock Issue of Consideration Subscribe Now

Final Decision

The Supreme Court allowed the writ petition, commuting the death sentence to life imprisonment due to inordinate delay in the disposal of the Mercy Petition and the conditions of solitary confinement.

Law Points

  • Article 32
  • delay in execution of death sentence
  • solitary confinement
  • commutation of death sentence
  • right to life
Subscribe to unlock Law Points Subscribe Now

Case Details

2014 LawText (SC) (12) 40

Writ Petition (Criminal) No.128 of 2014

2014-12-12

Uday Umesh Lalit, Dipak Misra, Rohinton Fali Nariman

Urmila Sirur, Ratan Kr. Choudhary, Binu Tamta, Sushma Suri

Ajay Kumar Pal

Union of India and Another

Subscribe to unlock Case Details (Citation, Judge, Date & more) Subscribe Now

Nature of Litigation

Writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India seeking commutation of death sentence.

Remedy Sought

Commutation of death sentence to life imprisonment.

Filing Reason

Inordinate delay in the disposal of the Mercy Petition and conditions of solitary confinement.

Previous Decisions

Death sentence confirmed by the Supreme Court on 16.03.2010.

Issues

Whether the delay in the disposal of the Mercy Petition constituted grounds for commutation of the death sentence. Whether the conditions of solitary confinement violated the petitioner's rights.

Submissions/Arguments

The petitioner argued that the delay in the disposal of the Mercy Petition was inordinate and unjust. The petitioner contended that solitary confinement since the death sentence was a violation of his rights.

Ratio Decidendi

Inordinate delay in the disposal of a Mercy Petition and prolonged solitary confinement can violate constitutional rights, warranting commutation of a death sentence to life imprisonment.

Judgment Excerpts

The time of 3 years and 10 months taken in disposal of the Mercy Petition and communicating the decision thereon is purely to the account of the authorities and functionaries concerned. The delay is not to the account of the petitioner or as a result of any proceedings initiated by him or on his behalf but is certainly to the account of the functionaries and authorities concerned. The combined effect of the inordinate delay in disposal of Mercy Petition and the solitary confinement for such a long period, in our considered view has caused deprivation of the most cherished right.

Procedural History

The petitioner was sentenced to death on 09.04.2007, confirmed by the Jharkhand High Court on 28.08.2007, and by the Supreme Court on 16.03.2010. Mercy Petitions were filed on 10.04.2010 and were not disposed of until 27.01.2014.

Acts & Sections

  • Constitution of India: Article 21, Article 32
  • Prisons Act, 1894: Section 30(2)
Subscribe to unlock full Legal Analysis Subscribe Now
Related Judgement
High Court Bombay High Court Upholds Partition Decree, Rejects Exclusive Ownership Claim Based on Tenancy Order. Civil Court Has Jurisdiction to Determine Whether Section 32G Order Was Obtained for Joint Family or Individual Capacity.
Related Judgement
Supreme Court Supreme Court Remands Pension Computation Case for Fresh Consideration Due to Applicability of Government Order. The Court directed the High Court to reassess the entitlement of past service benefits for pension computation in light of the Government...