Case Note & Summary
The Court has addressed cross appeals involving the Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Limited (TNMSC) and its employees' union regarding the applicability of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981. The High Court had previously affirmed that the Act applied to the Corporation, leading to an order to regularize 53 workmen. The Supreme Court upheld this judgment, dismissing the Corporation's appeal and confirming that the workmen were entitled to permanent status under the Act.
Impugned JudgmentThe High Court had directed the TNMSC to confer permanent status on 53 workmen, while rejecting the claim of 42 others.
Questions Before the CourtTwo main questions:
Applicability of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments Act, 1981 to TNMSC. Sustainability of the suggestion to institute an 'Industrial Disputes Claim'. Facts in BriefTNMSC was incorporated in 1994 under the Indian Companies Act, 1956, and managed by the State of Tamil Nadu. Employees sought regularization under the Tamil Nadu Act.
Directions of Learned Single JudgeThe Single Judge's directions included:
Application of the Act to TNMSC. Inspection and verification by the Labour Inspector. Consideration of employment claims on Saturdays. Inspector of Labour’s OrderThe Inspector of Labour granted permanent status to 53 workmen.
Appeals and ProceedingsThe High Court confirmed the Inspector's order, which led to civil appeals.
Supreme Court’s RemandThe Supreme Court, on 10th March 2016, remanded the matter to the High Court for reconsideration.
Impugned Judgment of High CourtThe High Court reaffirmed the applicability of the Act to TNMSC and directed the provision of permanent employment to the workmen.
Submissions of the PartiesArguments by TNMSC included non-applicability of the Act and other employment of workmen.
The Union argued exploitation of temporary employees and supported the Inspector’s order for permanent status.
Analysis and ConsiderationExamination of relevant provisions and activities of TNMSC leading to the conclusion that TNMSC is an industrial establishment under the Act.
Final JudgmentThe appeal by TNMSC is dismissed, and the Union's appeal is allowed, confirming permanent status for the workmen.
Pending ApplicationsPending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.
Issue of Consideration: Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Ltd. Versus Tamil Nadu Medical Services Corporation Employees Welfare Union & Anr.
Premium Content
The Issue of Consideration is only available to subscribed members.
Subscribe Now to access critical case issues
