Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from Special Civil Applications filed by individual police constables and the Gujarat Rajya Police Constable Karmchari Mandal against the Government of Gujarat's resolution dated 1-2-1984 concerning refreshment allowances. The petitioners sought to quash this resolution, arguing that it effectively negated a prior court decision from 1982 that mandated the payment of refreshment allowances to constables working over 12 hours. They contended that the new resolution imposed conditions that would prevent most officers from receiving the allowance, thus overreaching the earlier court order and violating the Police Manual. The respondents defended the resolution, asserting that the refreshment allowance was not an automatic right and that the government had considered the relevant provisions of the Police Manual. The court found it inappropriate for the petitioners to approach the court directly without first addressing their grievances to the government. It ruled that the petitioners could submit their concerns to the Secretary of the Home Department, who would then consider their representation and communicate the decision to the association's representatives. The court discharged the rule without costs.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Government Resolution - Challenge to Resolution on Refreshment Allowance - Constitution of India, 1950 - Petitioners contested the validity of the 1984 resolution, claiming it undermined a prior court order and was contrary to the Police Manual. The court directed that grievances should first be presented to the government, allowing for representation to be considered by the Secretary of the Home Department. Held that direct approach to court was not appropriate (Paras 3-6).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the resolution dated 1-2-1984 regarding refreshment allowance contravenes previous court orders and the Police Manual.
Final Decision
The court dismissed the petitions, directing the petitioners to approach the Secretary of the Home Department with their grievances regarding the resolution dated 1-2-1984. The Secretary was instructed to consider any representation made and communicate the decision to the association's representatives.
Law Points
- Government resolution
- refreshment allowance
- police manual
- representation to government
- judicial review


