Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a Special Civil Application filed by an employee of the accounts and treasury department against the Gujarat Civil Services Tribunal's decision regarding a penalty imposed on him. The petitioner was penalized with the withholding of three grade increments due to charges including wilful absence from duty. Following the penalty, the period of absence was regularized by an order dated 29th October 1983. However, the respondent failed to implement this order, prompting the petitioner to seek judicial intervention. The petitioner argued that the non-implementation was arbitrary and unjustified, especially since the absence had been regularized. The respondents did not provide a satisfactory explanation for their inaction. The court accepted the petitioner's first contention, emphasizing that the order for regularization was made in accordance with the Rules and should have been complied with. The court found no merit in the second contention regarding the penalty, noting that the Tribunal had already taken a lenient view. Ultimately, the court partially allowed the application, maintaining the Tribunal's order while directing the respondent to comply with the regularization order and provide consequential benefits within four months.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Implementation of Government Orders - Non-Compliance - Special Civil Application - The court found the action of the respondent in not implementing the order dated 29th October 1983 arbitrary as the order was made in accordance with the Rules and had to be complied with. The court directed compliance with the order and granted consequential benefits to the petitioner (Paras 5-7).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the action of the respondent in not implementing the order dated 29th October 1983 was arbitrary and unjustified.
Final Decision
The Special Civil Application was allowed in part. The Tribunal's order was maintained, and the respondent was directed to comply with the order dated 29th October 1983 and provide all consequential benefits within four months.
Law Points
- Arbitrariness in administrative action
- compliance with government orders
- disciplinary proceedings
- regularization of absence



