Case Note & Summary
The case involved a petition by an employee of the Gujarat Electricity Board seeking promotion benefits under the nine year rule as per General Standing Order No. 253. The petitioner joined as a Deputy Engineer on 7.10.1964 and claimed entitlement to promotion from 7.10.1973 after completing nine years of service. He argued that despite being punished for causing damage to property, he was unfairly denied the benefits from his due date, while others with similar or more severe punishments were granted their benefits. The court noted that the petitioner was subjected to a charge-sheet and received a penalty of stoppage of increments, but other officers who faced similar disciplinary actions were treated more favorably. The court found that the authorities had not provided any justifiable reason for the differential treatment and emphasized that the overall performance of the petitioner was satisfactory. The court referred to previous decisions that established criteria for granting benefits under the nine year rule, stating that adverse remarks not communicated were to be considered stale. Ultimately, the court ruled in favor of the petitioner, directing the respondents to grant him the benefits from his due date of 7.10.1973, making the rule absolute without costs.
Headnote
A) Service Law - Promotion Benefits - Entitlement under Nine Year Rule - General Standing Order No. 253, 1973 - The petitioner sought promotion benefits under the nine year rule from the date of completion of nine years of service, claiming discrimination as others received benefits despite similar punishments. The court held that the petitioner was entitled to the benefits from the due date, as there was no justifiable reason for differential treatment compared to other officers (Paras 1-12).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioner was entitled to promotion benefits under the nine year rule from the due date of 7.10.1973.
Final Decision
The court ruled in favor of the petitioner, directing the respondents to grant him the benefits of the nine year rule from his due date of 7.10.1973, making the rule absolute without costs.
Law Points
- Promotion benefits
- nine year rule
- discrimination in service
- General Standing Order
- departmental inquiry



