Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose between a registered Co-operative Housing Society and the State of Gujarat regarding the allotment of residential plots. The petitioner society, representing 15 members, sought allotment of 200 sq. mt. plots based on a certificate issued in 1974. However, subsequent government resolutions reduced the allotment size to 135 sq. mt. The petitioner initially received an allotment order for 15 plots but faced a reduction to 14 plots, leading to protests and further representations. After a series of communications and a cancellation order from the Additional Collector, the petitioner appealed to the Special Secretary, who remanded the case back for reconsideration. The District Collector later issued a cancellation order, which the petitioner contested, arguing that it violated principles of natural justice and ignored the Special Secretary's directives. The court found the Section Officer's order to be without authority and the District Collector's decision to be perverse, ultimately restoring the original allotment while limiting it to 12 members willing to accept the reduced plot size. The court also awarded costs against the State for the illegal actions of its officers. The judgment emphasized the importance of adhering to established government policies and the authority of officers in administrative decisions.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Jurisdiction of Officers - Section Officer's Authority - The order of the Section Officer dated 6-7-1982 was held to be arbitrary and without jurisdiction as it contradicted the earlier order of the Special Secretary and lacked legal authority. The court emphasized that the Section Officer could not supersede the decision of the Special Secretary regarding land allotment. Held that the order was illegal and could not stand (Paras 7-10). B) Co-operative Societies - Land Allotment Policy - The court found that the petitioner society's entitlement to plots of 200 sq. mt. was not valid post the Government resolution dated 25th July, 1974, which limited the allotment size to 135 sq. mt. The court ruled that the petitioner had no accrued right to the larger plots as the allotment was subject to the Government's policy. Held that the final allotment should be made according to the revised policy (Paras 10-11). C) Costs - Award of Costs - The court deemed the orders of the District Collector and Section Officer as perverse and illegal, directing the respondent to pay Rs.5000/- as costs for the litigation, with provisions for recovery from the erring officer (Paras 12).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the orders of the Section Officer and District Collector regarding land allotment were valid and lawful.
Final Decision
The court set aside the orders of the Section Officer and District Collector, restoring the original allotment of plots to the petitioner society for 12 members at the rate of Rs.10/- per sq. mt., while awarding costs of Rs.5000/- against the State.
Law Points
- Co-operative Societies
- Land Allotment
- Jurisdiction of Officers
- Natural Justice
- Government Resolutions



