Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the petitioners, members of a Cooperative Housing Society in Ahmedabad, seeking land allotment under a scheme for displaced persons. They migrated from Sindh, Pakistan, and settled in Sardarnagar, Ahmedabad. The petitioners applied for land to build houses, claiming eligibility under the Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954. After receiving a Land Availability Certificate, they paid the required amount but faced delays in final allotment due to differing income eligibility criteria set by a Committee and the Government. The petitioners contended that other societies with members exceeding the income limit were granted land, alleging discrimination. The court noted the lack of evidence from the petitioners to substantiate their claims of unequal treatment. It directed the Secretary of the Revenue Department to review the case, ensuring that the petitioners' rights were considered fairly, and emphasized the need for reasonable conditions on land use to prevent profit-making from the allotment. The court ordered the Secretary to decide the matter within three months after receiving the petitioners' documents, highlighting the importance of equitable treatment in land allotment processes.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Land Allotment - Eligibility Criteria - Displaced Persons (Compensation and Rehabilitation) Act, 1954 - The court examined the conflicting eligibility criteria set by the Committee and the Government regarding income limits for land allotment to displaced persons. It directed the Secretary of the Revenue Department to reconsider the petitioners' case afresh, ensuring fair treatment in line with similar societies (Paras 17).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioners are entitled to land allotment under the Cooperative Housing Scheme despite differing eligibility criteria set by the Committee and the Government.
Final Decision
The court directed the Secretary of the Revenue Department to reconsider the petitioners' case afresh, ensuring fair treatment and adherence to eligibility criteria. The Secretary was to decide within three months and consider the petitioners' submissions and the court's observations.
Law Points
- Displaced Persons Act
- Cooperative Societies Act
- eligibility criteria
- land allotment
- administrative discretion



