Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a petition filed by an Octroi Inspector challenging the rejection of a pay scale revision proposal by the first respondent. The petitioner, appointed on 22nd October 1969, contended that the pay scales for Shop Inspectors and Octroi Inspectors in Deesa Nagar Palika were the same, while the Food Inspector's scale was lower. Following the Desai Pay Commission's recommendations, the pay scale for Inspectors was revised to Rs.425-700 effective from 1.1.1977. The petitioner sought to have his pay scale revised to match this amount from 1.1.1973. Despite recommendations from both respondents Nos. 1 and 2 for the revision, the first respondent rejected the proposal without providing a reasoned order. The court found that the rejection was arbitrary and that the petitioner had a valid grievance since he was not granted the same benefits as other Inspectors. The court decided to allow the petition, set aside the non-speaking order, and directed the first respondent to reconsider the proposal, ensuring that if the revision was denied, a reasoned order was provided to the petitioner. The rule was made absolute in these terms.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Non-speaking Orders - Requirement of Reasoned Decisions - Constitution of India - The court held that an administrative authority must provide reasons when rejecting a proposal that aligns with recommendations from subordinate authorities. The absence of a reasoned order in this case was deemed arbitrary, necessitating a fresh consideration of the pay scale revision proposal (Paras 1-4).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the respondent acted arbitrarily in rejecting the pay scale revision proposal without providing reasons.
Final Decision
The court allowed the petition, set aside the order of respondent No.1 dated 19.3.1982, and directed respondent No.1 to reconsider the proposal for the pay scale revision, ensuring a reasoned order if the revision was denied.
Law Points
- Writ jurisdiction
- non-speaking orders
- pay scale revision
- administrative discretion



