Case Note & Summary
The case involved a challenge by a Class-II Gazetted officer of the Government of Gujarat against an order dated 24th January 1984, which imposed a penalty of withholding one grade increment with future effect. The petitioner contended that this penalty was a major one and could only be imposed following a departmental inquiry, which had not been conducted in this instance. The respondent's counsel did not dispute that withholding the increment was a major penalty or that no inquiry had been held. The court noted that the facts presented by the petitioner remained unchallenged due to the absence of a reply from the respondents. Consequently, the court determined that the imposition of the penalty without an inquiry was improper and set aside the order. However, it allowed the respondents to initiate a departmental inquiry if they wished, stipulating that a decision should be made within one month and the inquiry completed within six months thereafter. The court ruled in favor of the petitioner, making the rule absolute without costs.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Major Penalty - Requirement of Departmental Inquiry - Constitution of India, 1950 - The court held that withholding of one grade increment is a major penalty and cannot be imposed without a departmental inquiry. The order dated 24th January 1984 was set aside, allowing the respondents to conduct an inquiry if desired, within specified timelines. Held that due process must be followed in imposing major penalties (Paras 1-3).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the withholding of one grade increment constituted a major penalty requiring a departmental inquiry.
Final Decision
The court set aside the order dated 24th January 1984, allowing the respondents to conduct a departmental inquiry if desired, with specified timelines for decision and completion.
Law Points
- Major penalty
- Departmental inquiry
- Show cause notice
- Gazetted officer
- Constitutional interpretation



