Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a Special Civil Application filed by Mahendrakumar Nathalal Shah and others under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeking a direction for the reassessment of rent for premises rented to the Central Excise and Customs Department. The premises were rented out in 1975 at a rate of Rs.1.25 per sq.ft., amounting to Rs.1,348 per month, with a provision for rent revision every five years. The petitioners contended that the rent for the period 1982-87 needed reassessment, which was opposed by the respondents on grounds of delay. However, the court had previously rejected similar objections in another case. The CPWD had assessed the rent for various periods, indicating significant increases based on recognized principles and market rates. The court determined that the average rent for the periods in question should be fixed at Rs.3,170, Rs.5,031, Rs.8,068, and Rs.9,603 per month for the respective years. The court allowed the application, directing the respondents to adjust the rent accordingly and to continue payments at the newly fixed rate for the next five years. The court ordered that any excess payments made should be adjusted against future rent, with a timeline of two months for the calculation and payment of any dues. The rule was made absolute with no order as to costs.
Headnote
A) Constitutional Law - Article 226 - Reassessment of Rent - Special Civil Application for rent reassessment - Petitioner sought direction for reassessment of rent for the period 1982-87 and subsequent years based on CPWD assessments. Court allowed the application and directed the respondents to fix the rent as per the average rates determined by CPWD assessments for different periods. Held that the reassessment was justified and necessary adjustments to be made in future payments (Paras 1-5).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioner is entitled to a reassessment of rent for the premises and the appropriate rate for different periods.
Final Decision
The court allowed the Special Civil Application, directing the respondents to fix the rent as per the average rates determined by CPWD assessments for different periods and to continue payments at the rate of Rs.9,603 per month for the next five years. Adjustments for any excess payments were also ordered, with a timeline of two months for calculation and payment.
Law Points
- Article 226 of the Constitution of India
- reassessment of rent
- delay in approaching court
- CPWD rent assessment
- average rent calculation




