Case Note & Summary
The petitioner challenged a letter dated 30th December 1982, which denied him the deemed date of promotion to the post of Deputy Mamlatdar. The petitioner, a retired Circle Officer, contended that he was initially appointed as a Ledger Clerk in 1946 and had been promoted to Circle Inspector in 1984, serving until his retirement in 1981. He argued that he had made a representation in 1979 for the deemed date of promotion, which was rejected on the grounds of not passing the departmental examination and being in the Talati cadre in 1948. The petitioner pointed out that juniors had been promoted while he was denied the same benefit, despite the recruitment rules not mandating passing the examination for non-matriculate Clerks. The respondent's counsel argued that the petitioner had only briefly served as Talati and that he was not entitled to promotion under the rules. The court found that the Collector's decision was based solely on the assumption that the petitioner had not passed the examination, which was not a justifiable reason to deny promotion. The court noted that the State had not filed any response to the petitioner's contentions. Consequently, the court allowed the petition, directing the respondents to grant the deemed date of promotion, fix seniority, and provide pension and benefits, clarifying that these benefits would be notional.
Headnote
A) Service Law - Promotion - Deemed Date of Promotion - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - The petitioner challenged the denial of deemed date of promotion to Deputy Mamlatdar based on not passing the departmental examination. The court held that the reason provided was insufficient to deny promotion, directing the respondents to grant the deemed date of promotion and fix seniority accordingly (Paras 6-8).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioner was entitled to deemed date of promotion to the post of Deputy Mamlatdar despite not passing the departmental examination.
Final Decision
The petition was allowed, directing the respondents to grant the petitioner deemed date of promotion to the post of Mamlatdar, fix his seniority, and provide pension and consequential benefits, clarifying that the benefits would be notional.
Law Points
- Promotion
- Deemed Date
- Recruitment Rules
- Departmental Examination
- Seniority



