Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from the termination of a bus conductor's services by the appellant-Corporation for alleged misconduct, including failure to issue tickets and misappropriation of fare. The original respondent challenged this termination before the Labour Court, which ruled in his favor, granting him 60% backwages. The Corporation appealed this decision, leading to a series of interim orders, including a stay on the payment of backwages. The learned single Judge vacated the interim order, prompting the Corporation to appeal again. During the proceedings, the original respondent passed away, and his heirs were substituted. The court calculated the backwages due to the original respondent and found that, despite his reinstatement, he had been chargesheeted multiple times for misconduct. Consequently, the court decided to reduce the backwages from Rs.35,735 to Rs.20,000, ultimately directing the Corporation to pay a total of Rs.30,809 to the heirs. The court also noted that any grievances regarding gratuity calculations could be addressed separately by the widow of the original respondent.
Headnote
A) Employment Law - Termination of Service - Validity of Termination - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, Section 226 - The appellant-Corporation challenged the termination of the original respondent's services for misconduct. The court upheld the Labour Court's award but adjusted the backwages due to the respondent's repeated misconduct. Held that a reduced amount of backwages was justified (Paras 10-20).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the learned single Judge erred in vacating the interim order and the entitlement of backwages to the original respondent.
Final Decision
The Letters Patent Appeal and Special Civil Application No. 3283 of 1989 were partly allowed, directing the appellant-Corporation to pay Rs.30,809 to the heirs of the original respondent within eight weeks.
Law Points
- Employment law
- Labour Court awards
- Backwages entitlement
- Judicial review of interim orders




