Case Note & Summary
This case involved a Special Civil Application filed by the petitioner seeking directions for reassessment of rent for premises rented to the Central Excise and Customs department for the period from September 1, 1982, to August 31, 1987. The petitioner, Trupti Ramanlal Dave, contended that the rent had not been revised after the initial five-year period as per the agreement, which stipulated a revision based on CPWD assessments. The rent was initially set at Rs. 1,260 per month. A CPWD certificate dated October 24, 1994, indicated that the reasonable rent for the premises should be between Rs. 2,579 and Rs. 3,519. The respondent's counsel argued that the claim for reassessment prior to 1987 was barred by delay, citing various precedents where the courts had rejected petitions due to inordinate delay. However, the court found that the delay was not applicable in this case since the assessment was not done until 1994, and the respondents had already conceded to the revised rent from 1987 onwards. The court determined that the average rent should be fixed at Rs. 3,049 per month based on the CPWD assessment. Consequently, the court allowed the application, directing the respondents to pay the arrears of rent for the specified period and to adjust any excess payments against future rent. The court also provided a stay on the order for three weeks to allow the respondents to approach a higher forum. The ruling was made absolute with no order as to costs.
Headnote
A) Constitutional Law - Article 226 - Discretionary Power - The High Court's power under Article 226 is discretionary and may be exercised based on the explanation for delay in filing the petition. The court held that if there is no satisfactory explanation for inordinate delay, the petition may be rejected. (Paras 5-6). B) Rent Control - Reassessment of Rent - The court directed the respondents to reassess the rent for the period 1982-1987 based on the average market rate as per the CPWD certificate. The court found no justification for denying reasonable rent based on the assessment certificate issued in 1994. (Paras 9-10).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the petitioner is entitled to reassessment of rent for the period 1.9.1982 to 31.8.1987 despite the delay in filing the application.
Final Decision
The Special Civil Application was allowed, directing the respondents to reassess and pay the arrears of rent for the period from 1.9.1982 to 31.8.1987 at an average rate of Rs. 3,049 per month, with adjustments for any excess payments. The order was stayed for three weeks to allow for appeal.
Law Points
- discretionary power under Article 226
- doctrine of laches
- reasonable rent assessment
- delay in filing petition




