Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India by a police constable challenging his retirement on invalid pension. The petitioner joined the police service on 15-1-1977 and faced a significant disability after an accident in 1980 that led to the amputation of his left leg. Despite this, he continued to serve and was later trained as a VHP Operator. The retirement order dated 24-4-1985 was contested on the grounds that it violated Rule 202A(1) of the Bombay Civil Services Rules, which mandates specific procedures for declaring a government servant permanently incapacitated. The petitioner argued that he was not given an opportunity to appeal against the invalidation of his service. The respondents contended that the retirement was based on a medical board's report declaring him permanently unfit for service due to tuberculosis and other health issues. The court analyzed whether the retirement order adhered to the procedural requirements of the relevant rule. It found that the competent authority failed to inform the petitioner of his right to appeal and did not follow the necessary steps outlined in the rule. The court also noted that the petitioner was not provided with the medical certificate that justified the retirement decision. Consequently, the court quashed the retirement order, reinstated the petitioner as if he had never been retired, and directed the respondents to comply with the procedural requirements of Rule 202A(1) moving forward.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Invalid Pension - Compliance with Rule 202A(1) - Retirement on Invalid Pension - The court found that the order retiring the petitioner on invalid pension did not comply with the procedural requirements of Rule 202A(1) of the Bombay Civil Services Rules, as the petitioner was not informed of his right to appeal nor was the necessary conclusion reached by the competent authority. The court held that the order was invalid and quashed it, directing compliance with the rule from the appropriate stage (Paras 6-8).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the order to retire the petitioner on invalid pension was in accordance with the provisions of Rule 202A(1) of the Bombay Civil Services Rules.
Final Decision
The court allowed the petition, quashed the retirement order, and directed that the petitioner be treated as continuing in service with all benefits.
Law Points
- Article 226
- Bombay Civil Service Rules
- Rule 202A(1)
- natural justice
- invalid pension



