Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a challenge to a seniority list for junior clerks prepared by the State of Gujarat. The petitioner, A.I. Multani, was appointed as a junior clerk on 6-3-1969 and claimed that the seniority list dated 20-12-1980, which placed him at serial No. 227, was improperly prepared under the Gujarat Non Secretariat Clerks, Typists and Typists (Direct Recruitment Procedure) Rules, 1970. The petitioner argued that seniority should be determined based on merit as per Rule 29 of the Rules. However, the court noted that the seniority list had not been produced before it, and the petitioner referred to it as provisional, indicating that the writ petition was premature. Additionally, the court highlighted that individuals ranked above the petitioner were not joined as parties, which would violate principles of natural justice. The court also referenced other pending petitions challenging the same seniority list, indicating that the matter was still under consideration. Ultimately, the court dismissed the special civil application, stating that it did not survive due to the reasons outlined, including the provisional nature of the seniority list and the lack of necessary parties. The court discharged the rule without costs.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Seniority Determination - Validity of Seniority List - Gujarat Non Secretariat Clerks, Typists and Typists (Direct Recruitment Procedure) Rules, 1970, Rule 29 - The petitioner challenged the seniority list circulated on 20-12-1980, claiming it was not prepared according to merit. The court held that the list was provisional and not final, and the absence of necessary parties made the petition not maintainable (Paras 3-5).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the seniority list prepared for junior clerks was valid and whether the petitioner had the right to challenge it.
Final Decision
The special civil application was dismissed, and the rule was discharged due to the provisional nature of the seniority list and the absence of necessary parties.
Law Points
- seniority determination
- provisional seniority list
- natural justice
- necessary parties
- Gujarat Non Secretariat Clerks Rules



