Case Note & Summary
The dispute arose from a group of Special Civil Applications filed by the petitioners against a recovery notice issued by the Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited for the difference in cement purchase price. The petitioners contended that the recovery was illegal as they were not given an opportunity to contest the price determination. The respondent corporation explained that prior to October 1, 1987, cement prices were fixed by subordinate Revenue Officers considering various factors, and a uniform price was established by a government resolution effective from October 1, 1981. The recovery was related to the price difference payable to the Cement Price Equilisation Fund. After reviewing the submissions, the court found no merit in the petitions, stating that the price determination was lawful and the petitioners' grievances were not valid. Consequently, the court rejected the applications, discharged the rule, and vacated the interim relief, although it provided a two-month period before any coercive recovery measures could be taken.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Recovery Notice - Validity of Recovery Notice - Cement Control Order, 1967 - Petitioners challenged the recovery notice for price difference without prior determination of the dispute and opportunity to be heard. Court held that the price was fixed legally under the Cement Control Order and the grievance was unsustainable. (Paras 1-2)
Issue of Consideration
Whether the recovery notice issued by the respondent was valid and whether the petitioners were given an opportunity to contest the price determination.
Final Decision
The court rejected the group of Special Civil Applications, finding no merit in the petitioners' claims. The rule was discharged in each petition, and the interim relief was vacated, although the respondent was restrained from taking coercive measures for recovery for two months.
Law Points
- Recovery notice
- Cement Control Order
- Uniform pricing
- Authority of law
- Opportunity to be heard



