Case Note & Summary
The dispute involved multiple Special Civil Applications concerning the promotion of a petitioner who joined the Kutch District Local Board as a Junior Clerk in 1954 and was confirmed in 1955. The petitioner claimed that he was unfairly denied a deemed date of promotion compared to junior employees who had not passed the required Accounts examination. The petitioner passed the examination in 1967, but his deemed date of promotion was set to 1966, while juniors were promoted earlier. The petitioner appealed against the changing of his deemed date of promotion, which was initially set by the Additional Development Commissioner in 1975. The District Development Officer later altered this date, leading to the petitioner's appeal to the Gujarat Civil Services Tribunal, which was dismissed. The court found that the authorities had not adequately considered the petitioner's claims in light of the promotions granted to junior employees. The court quashed the District Development Officer's order and reinstated the original deemed date of promotion based on seniority, allowing the petitioners' claims and granting them relief without costs.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Promotion and Seniority - Deemed Date of Promotion - Gujarat Civil Services Tribunal, 1984 - The court held that the District Development Officer erred in not considering the petitioners' claims for deemed date of promotion with reference to a junior employee's case, which was crucial for determining their rightful promotion. The court quashed the order changing the deemed date of promotion and reinstated the original date based on seniority (Paras 9-12).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the deemed date of promotion for the petitioners should be reconsidered based on their seniority and the cases of junior employees.
Final Decision
The court quashed the order of the District Development Officer dated 4th February 1982, reinstating the original deemed date of promotion for the petitioner as 27th October 1963, and allowed the Special Civil Applications with no order as to costs.
Law Points
- Promotion
- deemed date
- seniority
- administrative law
- public service rules



