Case Note & Summary
The case involved a writ petition filed by a former Talati who challenged the Collector's order that cancelled his previously accepted date of birth, leading to his deemed retirement. The petitioner was appointed in 1944 and had his date of birth recorded as 30th May 1923 in the service records, which he contested with a school certificate stating his birth date as 7th November 1926. After verification, the Collector had accepted the latter date and allowed the petitioner to continue in service until 1983. However, a show cause notice was issued by the Collector in 1983, questioning the validity of the accepted date of birth. The petitioner argued that the records from the erstwhile Princely State of Kutch were poorly maintained, and the verification process was flawed. The court noted that the Collector's actions were arbitrary and lacked justification, especially since the date of birth had been accepted and acted upon for several years. The court ultimately quashed the Collector's order, allowing the writ petition and reinstating the accepted date of birth, emphasizing the need for administrative actions to be based on verified and accurate records.
Headnote
A) Administrative Law - Writ Jurisdiction - Validity of Administrative Orders - Constitution of India, 1950 - The court found the Collector's cancellation of the petitioner's date of birth arbitrary as it was based on previously accepted documentation and verification. The petitioner had provided sufficient evidence to support his claim, which was accepted by the competent authority, thus the cancellation order was quashed. Held that administrative decisions must be based on verified records and proper procedures (Paras 6-10).
Issue of Consideration
Whether the order of the Collector cancelling the petitioner's date of birth and retirement was justified.
Final Decision
The court quashed the Collector's order dated 20th May, 1983, allowing the writ petition and reinstating the petitioner's date of birth as 7-11-1926. The court ruled that the administrative action was arbitrary and lacked proper justification.
Law Points
- Writ jurisdiction
- service records
- date of birth verification
- arbitrary administrative action



